charles at FREUDE.COM
Mon Jun 17 15:37:58 UTC 2002
I say "dog" with the caught vowel and all other -og words with the cob
vowel (not distinguished in my Atlanta-based dialect from the a in father).
Like Alice Faber, I was bothered as a child by verse that rhymed dog with
I also noticed when I was young that we said "got" differently from other
-ot words, so got and hot don't rhyme; the vowel in "got" is higher, and is
the same except for length as the monophthong in "ride". (I say "right" as
a diphthong, however.) Thus this short vowel occurs in exactly one word in
my dialect, except when I am imitating hillbillies. I understand that this
feature of the Atlanta dialect has been noticed by linguists. Does that
mean it is an extra phoneme?
There are apparently phenomena like this in Cantonese and in Arabic: In
Cantonese, there is one tone that is used in exactly one fairly common
word, nowhere else. And in standard modern Arabic there is supposedly a
sound used only in the word "Allah" and nowhere else, but I forget the details.
My Cantonese informant once told me, "Cantonese has nine tones, but it only
uses seven." Now just what does that mean...?
professional website: http://www.cwru.edu/artsci/math/wells/home.html
personal website: http://www.oberlin.net/~cwells/index.html
NE Ohio Sacred Harp website: http://www.oberlin.net/~cwells/sh.htm
More information about the Ads-l