Dutch Treat (1885)
maberry at U.WASHINGTON.EDU
Wed Nov 6 18:27:05 UTC 2002
On Wed, 6 Nov 2002, James A. Landau wrote:
> An odd thing about the OED text: The Arabs led the world in geography and
> many other intellectual pursuits from the rise of Islam to roughly the
> Renaissance. However, as far as I know, there were no works of geography
> written in Arabic before Muhammed.
Other than some inscriptions and a few papyri (as far as I know, none of
them about geography or North Africa), there aren't any written Arabic
documents before Muhammad, at least none that survived if they existed at
all. There is a corpus of pre-Islamic poetry, but again that wasn't
recorded in writing until after Muhammad.
> Or am I wrong and there do exist
> documents from pre-Moslem Arabia that apply "B-R-B-R" (Barbar, Berber when
> vowels are added) to North Africa?
None that I know of.
> (Incidentally, I'm not saying that the Arabic word BRBR is from Greek, but
> Arabia had Greek-speaking neighbors in the Fertile Crescent from the days of
> Alexander the Great until the Islamic conquest of the Fertile Crescent, which
> was nine or ten centuries, so the Greek word could have travelled into Arabia
> during that time.)
Lane's Arabic-English Lexicon has this under barbar, "a foreign word
[probably of African origin the primary form of which is the source of
[Greek] Barbaros, or as some suggest from [Arabic] barbarah in speech"
So Lane would derive both the Arabic AND Greek words from some common
African original. Unfortunately he does not give more details.
maberry at u.washington.edu
More information about the Ads-l