Dueling dialects

[Laurence Horn]

At 4:12 PM -0400 8/20/04, Wilson Gray wrote:
>On Aug 20, 2004, at 9:43 AM, Ed Keer wrote:

Actually the below claims about NYC non-neutralization were mine, not
Ed's.  Ed's observations concerned the Philly "Murray Christmas"
dialect below.

>
>>---------------------- Information from the mail header
>>-----------------------
>>Sender:       American Dialect Society <ADS-L at LISTSERV.UGA.EDU>
>>Poster:       Ed Keer <edkeer at YAHOO.COM>
>>Subject:      Re: Dueling dialects
>>-----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>--------
>>
>>>You bring up, I believe, the issue of pre-rhotic
>>>front non-high vowel
>>>neutralization vs. differentiation, which is
>>>certainly not constant
>>>across European-American dialects.
>
>Of course it isn't.
>
>>>   As a duellist
>>>who happens to hail
>>>from NYC, I maintain the classical 3-way
>>>distinction:  Mary [e],
>>>merry [E], marry [ae].  -arry names like "Barry" or
>>>"Harry" (I could
>>>never understand those "Harry"/"hairy" puns) have
>>>the [ae] vowel of
>>>"bat".
>
>This is basically the system used in East Texas. I say "basically"
>because you have to factor in the Southern drawl, etc. However, the St.
>Louis dialect once again appears to be skewed, compared to others.
>E.g., Harry/hairy puns are transparent to anyone from St. Louis, since
>they both have the [ae] vowel of "bat." You know, I've had a sudden
>flash of insight. I used to know a kid named "Harry Balls." I often
>wondered what this guy's parents could have been thinking, that they
>would name their child "hairy balls."
>...
>>
>>
>>No way, the classical 3-way distinction was: Mary [e],
>>merry [@], marry [ae]. Any other pronunciation is
>>barbaric :)
>>
>>Ed (from SE PA/Philly)
>>
>>
>>
>>_______________________________
>>Do you Yahoo!?
>>Win 1 of 4,000 free domain names from Yahoo! Enter now.
>>http://promotions.yahoo.com/goldrush