The artist, the shoemaker, and the sandal

ronbutters at AOL.COM ronbutters at AOL.COM
Mon Aug 16 13:38:45 UTC 2010

Well, what about high heels! A rather ill-considered proverb. Should the linguist not go beyond simple sentences?
------Original Message------
From: Joel S. Berson
Sender: ADS-L
ReplyTo: ADS-L
Subject: [ADS-L] The artist, the shoemaker, and the sandal
Sent: Aug 16, 2010 8:32 AM

For the forthcoming Yale Book of Proverbs?

"A shoemaker in his criticism must not go beyond the sandal."

Or is this just a variant (or vice versa) of "the cobbler should
stick to his last"?

 From another list (probable typos corrected):
>Ne sutor ultra crepidam--Apelles and the cobbler, as told by Pliny
>(Natural History, Bk 35, 84-85):
>"Another habit of his [Apelles, the great Greek artist] was when he
>had finished his works to place them in a gallery in the view of
>passers by, and he himself stood out of sight behind the picture and
>listened ot [to] hear what faults were noticed, rating the public as
>a more observant critic than himself. And it is said that he was
>found fault with by a shoemaker because in drawing a subject's
>sandals he had represented the loops in them as one too few, and the
>next day the same critic was so proud of the artist's correcting the
>fault indicated by his previous objection that he found fault with
>the leg, but Apelles indignantly looked out from behind the picture
>and rebuked him, saying that a shoemaker in his criticism must not
>go beyond the sandal--a remarked [remark] that has also passed into a proverb."

14 Google Books hits.


The American Dialect Society -

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

The American Dialect Society -

More information about the Ads-l mailing list