laurence.horn at YALE.EDU
Sat Nov 26 01:13:38 UTC 2011
On Nov 25, 2011, at 7:59 PM, James A. Landau wrote:
> On Wed, 23 Nov 2011 10:21:58 zone minus 0500 Laurence Horn <laurence.horn at YALE.EDU> writes:
>> Unless I missed it, nobody has commented on the recent flap over Rush Limbaugh's use of "uppity" to >describe Michelle Obama. Glenn Beck has since defended Limbaugh on the grounds that "uppity" is just a
>> synonym for "snobbish".
> When I saw the headline on Netscape News, my first thought was "I should hope so. I'd hate to discover she's an Aunt Thomasina."
> One can claim "uppity" is a "racist" word, but I think not. What happens is that "uppity" has such a specific meaning that it rarely occurs outside a race-relations context, which means that the text surrounding the word can easily be racist, but not the word itself.
> "Uppity" can most easily be defined by naming its antonym: "Uncle Tom/Aunt Thomasina".
> A brief excursion into the socio-political realm. In the heyday of Segregation (note the capital "S"), Segregationists by-and-large were not so much black-haters as people desirious that "[blacks] know their place". An "uppity [black]" was a black who objected to being "kept in his place". Well, times change, and while racism unfortunately still exists, the old "stay in their place" paradigm no longer exists. As a spectacular example, the supporters of Clarence Thomas for the Supreme Court included a large number of white right-wing  bigots. But "keeping Thomas in his place"? Not hardly.
And along these lines, some of the coverage of the Limbaugh usage included a clip of the Clarence Thomas confirmation hearings, when he claimed that he was the victim of a high-tech lynching because he was "uppity". So for the white-wingers there's good uppity and bad uppity. Neither, however, in active use to describe the melanin-challenged.
> [I would like to thank my friend Jackie Gomberg MD (not to be confused with my friend Jackie Goldberg MD) for suggests a useful shorthand phrase: "white-wingers".)
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org
More information about the Ads-l