Any lessons from Russia?
Francis M Hult
fmhult at DOLPHIN.UPENN.EDU
Wed Mar 3 17:12:40 UTC 2004
>>From BBC News
Any lessons from Russia?
By Mike Baker
BBC education correspondent, in Moscow
School inspectors in England have warned that too much focus on basic
maths and English skills is destroying any chance of a "rich and
Russians, it seems, have the same fears.
Schools there achieve great success in literacy and numeracy. The
literacy rate for the whole adult population is around 95%.
This is partly due to the inheritance of the Soviet education system
which was strong on the "Three Rs". However, it was not so good at
encouraging creativity or thinking skills.
That is changing now: alongside the social and economic reforms of the
"new Russia", there is big push to reform the school curriculum and
Rote learning is on its way out and problem-solving and creative
thinking are on the way in.
In his Moscow office, the Russian Minister of Education, Vladimir
Filippov, told me "there was too much rote learning in the past and
there still is".
Mr Filippov is trying to push through widespread school reforms, many of
which are meeting resistance from teachers.
He is reducing the amount of factual detail students need to know to
pass frequent tests.
Mr Filippov said: "It is not necessary to know all the facts. We try to
give them the chance to think and to be creative."
In primary school, the government plans to do away with the formal
requirements to get "marks" in factual tests in music, sport and design.
In an education system with 63,000 schools - two-thirds of them in rural
areas very remote from Moscow - reform is not easy.
However, like Russian society, schools are changing. One of the
showcases is School 1674 (all Russian schools are known by numbers not
names) in the Krylatskoye suburb of Moscow.
It is a state-run nursery and primary school for 180 children aged three
to 10. It is an experimental school which has taken advantage of new
freedoms to innovate.
The school is open from 7 am until 6 pm with pupils able to stay the
whole time if their parents wish. There is a strong emphasis on
children's health: even the youngest have up to three hours a day of
physical activity, either walking or skiing in the nearby woods. There
are weekly sports competitions.
Much of the teaching is based on what the head teacher, Lyudmila
Suprunova, describes as "learning through play".
However, although the school is well-equipped, there were far fewer wall
displays of children's work than in most English schools and the
atmosphere was more ordered and formal. Children sat in rows and stood
up when visitors entered the classroom.
Although School 1674 is moving towards a more informal, creative
approach, it still has formal lessons which are currently unimaginable
in England. For example, some of the children here have been learning a
foreign language - English - since the age of three.
In the infant school, children learn it through poems, songs and games;
but by the junior school, from age six, they learn formal grammar.
In the third-grade English class Natalya Ivankova was teaching nine year
olds the "future indefinite tense of the future simple".
She told me she hoped her pupils had already mastered the "present
simple, the present continuous, and the past indefinite tenses, as well
as knowing their regular and irregular verbs, and adjectives and
I doubt if many English nine year olds would know this amount of grammar
in their own language, never mind a foreign one.
While School 1674 is exceptional, the concept of learning through play -
still new in Russia - is spreading elsewhere and parents are
increasingly willing to play their part.
The Little Genius shop and playgroup in a suburban shopping mall is a
As well as selling developmental games, it runs classes for children
aged between three and nine.
Parents pay about £2 an hour for their children to attend either before
or after school, or at weekends or holidays.
This combination of a market-related business and new educational
methods was the idea of Albina Yermakova, a former actress who now runs
three Little Genius stores in Moscow.
While prices are cheap by British standards, £2 an hour is expensive
compared to the average Moscow teacher's salary of between £100 to £200
President Putin's Russia appears to be as focused on educational reform
as Tony Blair's Britain: no part of the educational system is being left
untouched, from primary school to university.
But while Russian government reforms are aimed at developing greater
creativity and thinking skills, the reforms in England have been pushing
for greater emphasis on the basics.
However, one problem both countries face is a difficulty recruiting and
retaining teachers. Whereas in England teachers are often forced out by
problems of pupil discipline, in Russia the root cause is pay.
In Moscow, in particular, teachers of English, IT and PE have left in
droves to work in foreign-language schools, business and in health
The Moscow city authorities pay a premium of up to 80% above the
national pay scale. But this is still not enough. Many teachers only
survive by moonlighting in other jobs, especially private tuition.
>>From 1 January next year, though, the federal government plans a major
overhaul of teachers' pay and conditions. In return for a 50% pay rise,
Mr Filippov is proposing to introduce a standard 36-hour week.
This might appear attractive at first, but Russian teachers are not
At present they are not required to be at school all week, but only to
teach a certain number of classroom hours, typically 12, 18 or 24. The
rest of the time they are free to earn money privately outside school,
although they do have to spend time on preparation and marking.
Svetlana Vysotina has taught for 20 years and is head of English at
State Secondary School 1253. She earns about £200 a month, which she
supplements by providing private English lessons.
She loves her job but is not keen on the minister's proposals.
"I am very satisfied now, as I have the freedom to go out of school",
she said, "but I would not like to be required to be in school for a
fixed 36 hours."
The other big reform planned by Mr Filippov has parallels with the
Tomlinson Review of the curriculum in England, due to be published
But while Mr Tomlinson wants to encourage students to study a wider
range of subjects, the Russian plans are for the opposite: greater
specialism for 16 to 18 year olds.
The Russian secondary-school curriculum is very broad. In the last year
of compulsory schooling, most 15 to 16 year olds study 12 compulsory
This breadth is not reduced for those who stay on into high school - the
equivalent of Sixth Form. At School 1253 they take no fewer than 14
subjects, making England's 4 subjects at AS-level look very narrow
However, for the past two years Russian schools have been trialling a
new approach which involves specialising in just four or five subjects,
with study in the remaining subjects required at only a "basic" level.
In this respect, it is much closer to a French-style baccalaureate.
At School 1253 they recently introduced three "streams" in high school,
with students choosing to specialise in economics, medical studies or
The Russian school system is certainly changing. Mr Filppov is
understood to be close to Putin, who looks certain to be re-elected next
So the reforms will be pushed through.
The biggest threat to their success remains the problems of teachers'
pay and recruitment.
Male teachers are fast becoming an extinct species in Moscow. At School
1253 there are just three men out of a teaching staff of 62.
Three others left teaching recently because they could not afford to
support their families.
When I asked a class of 17 year olds if any of them planned to become
teachers, not a single one raised their hand. The "new Russians" in
Moscow want careers in business or computing.
>>From a British perspective, the strengths of the Russian school system
are clear: high levels of numeracy and literacy, impressive
foreign-language skills, very few discipline problems and a culture that
There are serious problems, though: school funding, teacher shortages, a
curriculum that is heavily focused on facts and rote learning, rather
than skills and creativity.
A report by the education watchdog Ofsted this week highlighted the
risks in England of focusing so much on the basics that the broader
Russia's challenge is the mirror-image: how to develop creativity and
choice in the curriculum without losing the firm foundations in grammar,
maths and foreign languages.
We welcome your comments at educationnews at bbc.co.uk although we cannot
always answer individual e-mails.
Story from BBC NEWS:
More information about the Edling