ELL: how much to spend on language technologies

Jeff ALLEN jeff at elda.fr
Tue Apr 6 17:52:18 UTC 1999


									 ***
                                                                             EOOH
                                                                             ***
									     Return-Path:
                                                                             <owner-endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au>
									     X-Authentication-Warning:
                                                                             carmen.murdoch.edu.au:
                                                                             majodomo
                                                                             set
                                                                             sender
                                                                             to
                                                                             owner-endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au
                                                                             using
                                                                             -f
									     X-Sender:
                                                                             jeff!elda.fr at 192.168.1.1
									     Date:
                                                                             Tue,
                                                                             06
                                                                             Apr
                                                                             1999
                                                                             19:52:18
                                                                             +0200
									     To:
                                                                             endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au
									     From:
                                                                             Jeff
                                                                             ALLEN
                                                                             <jeff at elda.fr>
									     Subject:
                                                                             ELL:
                                                                             how
                                                                             much
                                                                             to
                                                                             spend
                                                                             on
                                                                             language
                                                                             technologies
									     In-Reply-To:
                                                                             <Pine.GSO.3.96.990402121220.14250C-100000 at darkwing.uoregon.
									      edu>
									      Content-Type:
                                                                             text/plain;
                                                                             charset="iso-8859-1"
									     X-MIME-Autoconverted:
                                                                             from
                                                                             quoted-printable
                                                                             to
                                                                             8bit
                                                                             by
                                                                             carmen.murdoch.edu.au
                                                                             id
                                                                             CAA15859
									     Sender:
                                                                             owner-endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au
									     Precedence:
                                                                             bulk
									     Reply-To:
                                                                             endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au

									     At
									     12:23
									     02/04/99
									     -0800,
									     Scott
									     D. wrote:
									     >On
									     Thu,
									     1
									     Apr
									     1999,
									     David
									     Harris
									     wrote:
									     >
									     >>
									     Presumably,
									     the
									     Navajos
									     or
									     the
									     Cherokees
									     could
									     figure
									     out
									     a
									     way
									     to
									     raise
									     >>
									     that
									     kind
									     of
									     money. But
									     the
									     money
									     could
									     presumably
									     be
									     put
									     to
									     better
									     use
									     on
									     >>
									     improving
									     the
									     living
									     conditions
									     of
									     tribe
									     members.

									     Scott
									     D. wrote:
									     >And,
									     if
									     they
									     or
									     any
									     other
									     tribe
									     had
									     $100,000
									     to
									     spend
									     on
									     language
									     >maintenance,
									     there
									     are
									     much
									     better
									     ways
									     it
									     could
									     be
									     spent.


									     No
									     disagreement
									     with
									     this
									     point.

									     >It's
                                                                              a
									      ridiculously
									      unrealistic
									      amount
									      for
									      most
									      of
									      the
									      communities
									      >that
									      I'm
									      in
									      contact
									      with
									      or
									      know
									      anything
									      about.
									      <snip>
									      >
									      Even
									      the
									      best-funded
									      >programs
									      I
									      know
									      of
									      couldn't
									      spent
									      $100,000
									      at
									      a
									      shot
									      without
									      >giving
									      up
									      half
									      or
									      more
									      of
									      their
									      language
									      maintenance
									      activities
									      for
									      >a
									      year.

									      Comments
									      that
									      I
									      have
									      received
									      from
									      many
									      Haitians
									      regarding
									      my
									      computational
									      research
									      and
									      development
									      of
									      non-commercial
									      applications
									      (OCR,
									      spelling
									      checkers,
									      machine
									      translation,
									      speech
									      recognition)
									      for
									      their
									      language
									      is
									      that
									      those
									      in
									      the
									      country
									      are
									      probably
									      more
									      concerned
									      with
									      funding
									      the
									      construction
									      of
									      waterways,
									      roads,
									      and
									      development
									      of
									      crops
									      than
									      spending
									      money
									      on
									      the
									      standardization
									      of
									      the
									      language.

									      This
									      seems
									      to
									      line
									      up
									      with
									      Scott's
									      comments
									      for
									      the
									      most
									      part.

									      But
									      then,
									      TeleHaiti
									      invited
									      me
									      for
									      a
									      television
									      interview
									      during
									      my
									      last
									      trip
									      to
									      Haiti.
									      The
									      interview
									      aired
									      the
									      same
									      evening
									      and
									      the
									      next
									      morning.
									      This
									      aroused
									      a
									      lot
									      of
									      interest
									      for
									      the
									      Haitian
									      Kreyol
									      language
									      that
									      is
									      spoken
									      by
									      95%
									      of
									      the
									      population,
									      is
									      considered
									      to
									      be
									      a
									      co-official
									      language
									      with
									      French,
									      but
									      the
									      government
									      does
									      nothing
									      to
									      support
									      it.
									      What
									      I
									      did,
									      and
									      would
									      like
									      to
									      see
									      continue,
									      is
									      the
									      training
									      of
									      Haitians
									      on
									      such
									      computer
									      systems
									      so
									      that
									      they
									      can
									      continue
									      the
									      work
									      themselves,
									      possibly
									      with
									      external
									      funding,
									      and
									      develop
									      such
									      projects
									      into
									      something
									      that
									      becomes
									      Haitian-owned,
									      rather
									      than
									      continued
									      to
									      be
									      identified
									      with
									      the
									      outsiders
									      like
									      myself.

									      Best,

									      Jeff

=================================================
Jeff ALLEN - Directeur Technique
European Language Resources Association (ELRA)  &
European Language resources Distribution Agency (ELDA)
(Agence Europ.enne de Distribution des Ressources Linguistiques)
55, rue Brillat-Savarin
75013   Paris   FRANCE
Tel: (+33) 1.43.13.33.33 - Fax: (+33) 1.43.13.33.30
mailto:jeff at elda.fr
http://www.icp.grenet.fr/ELRA/home.html
----
Endangered-Languages-L Forum: endangered-languages-l at carmen.murdoch.edu.au
Web pages http://carmen.murdoch.edu.au/lists/endangered-languages-l/
Subscribe/unsubscribe and other commands: majordomo at carmen.murdoch.edu.au
----




More information about the Endangered-languages-l mailing list