Reference question -- Solved

[Andrew Carnie]

Sorry,

Never mind, minutes after sending my last message I found the reference.
(McCawley  1968 is the source for both ideas, although he cites Stockwell,
Bowen & Martin (1964) for the projection hypothesis, and attributes the node
admissability hypothesis to a personal communication with Richard
Stanley). If anyone knows of a different or earlier citation I'd like to
hear.

Best & Apologies for flooding your inboxes.

A



On Sun, 12 Feb 2006, Andrew Carnie wrote:

> Hi All,
>
> I'm totally blanking on a reference here, who was it (and where was it)
> that proposed that PSRs should be viewed as conditions on trees rather
> than deriving them (was it Gazdar 77?).
>
> While we're at it does anyone know who first proposed that PSRs were
> bottom to top projection rules rather than top to bottom replacement
> rules?
>
> Arghghgh this is driving me crazy! I hate it when I can't remember simple
> things like this.
>
> Best,
>
> A
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 	/ \			Andrew Carnie, Ph.D.
>        /   \	  		Assoc. Professor of Linguistics
>      	  / \    		Department of Linguistics
>      	 /   \			Douglass 200E, University of Arizona
>     	    / \			Tucson, AZ 85721
> 	   /   \
> 				Tel: (520) 621 2802  Cell: (520) 971 1166
> 				http://linguistics.arizona.edu/~carnie
>

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
	/ \			Andrew Carnie, Ph.D.
       /   \	  		Assoc. Professor of Linguistics
     	  / \    		Department of Linguistics
     	 /   \			Douglass 200E, University of Arizona
    	    / \			Tucson, AZ 85721
	   /   \
				Tel: (520) 621 2802  Cell: (520) 971 1166
				http://linguistics.arizona.edu/~carnie