17.1541, Review: Historical/Comparative Ling: Krishnamurti (2003)

[linguist at LINGUISTLIST.ORG]

LINGUIST List: Vol-17-1541. Thu May 18 2006. ISSN: 1068 - 4875.

Subject: 17.1541, Review: Historical/Comparative Ling: Krishnamurti (2003)

Moderators: Anthony Aristar, Wayne State U <aristar at linguistlist.org>
            Helen Aristar-Dry, Eastern Michigan U <hdry at linguistlist.org>
 
Reviews (reviews at linguistlist.org) 
        Sheila Dooley, U of Arizona  
        Terry Langendoen, U of Arizona  

Homepage: http://linguistlist.org/

The LINGUIST List is funded by Eastern Michigan University, Wayne
State University, and donations from subscribers and publishers.

Editor for this issue: Lindsay Butler <lindsay at linguistlist.org>
================================================================  

This LINGUIST List issue is a review of a book published by one of our
supporting publishers, commissioned by our book review editorial staff. We
welcome discussion of this book review on the list, and particularly invite
the author(s) or editor(s) of this book to join in. To start a discussion of
this book, you can use the Discussion form on the LINGUIST List website. For
the subject of the discussion, specify "Book Review" and the issue number of
this review. If you are interested in reviewing a book for LINGUIST, look for
the most recent posting with the subject "Reviews: AVAILABLE FOR REVIEW", and
follow the instructions at the top of the message. You can also contact the
book review staff directly.


===========================Directory==============================  

1)
Date: 15-May-2006
From: Basanti Devi < basanti9 at rediffmail.com >
Subject: The Dravidian Languages 

	
-------------------------Message 1 ---------------------------------- 
Date: Thu, 18 May 2006 21:40:06
From: Basanti Devi < basanti9 at rediffmail.com >
Subject: The Dravidian Languages 
 

Announced at http://linguistlist.org/issues/13/13-171.html 

AUTHOR: Krishnamurti, Bhadriraju 
TITLE: The Dravidian Languages
SERIES: Cambridge Language Surveys
PUBLISHER: Cambridge University Press
YEAR: 2003

Basanti Devi, Associate Professor, JSS Institute of Speech & Hearing, 
Mysore, India

DESCRIPTION

This book deals with historical and comparative aspects of the 
Dravidian languages. It will undoubtedly meet the requirements of a 
variety of readers. The book, a result of extensive research, can be 
treated as an authentic source book on the entire Dravidian language 
family, the world's fifth largest; it can be used as a reference book by 
students as well as scholars of linguistics. More specifically, it will 
cater to the needs of scholars involved in research in historical and 
comparative aspects of Dravidian languages. Scholars of contrastive 
linguistics and linguistic typology will also benefit from it. 

The book is divided into eleven chapters including an introduction and 
a conclusion. A list of tables (pp xii-xiv), note on transliteration and 
symbols (pp xx-xxii), abbreviations used (pp xxiii-xxvii), bibliography 
(pp 504-533) and a general index of subjects and names are also 
provided.

Chapter 1: Introduction
The book begins with clarification of the term 'Dravidian' which is 
generic in nature used to refer to a family of languages. The author 
also includes a brief discussion of the people speaking these 
languages and their cultures. Geographic and demographic 
distribution of the sub-groups as well as individual languages 
belonging to this family is outlined. The introduction includes a brief 
note on the typological features of Dravidian languages. It also 
contains an overview of previous work on these languages. Finally, 
the author has devoted a few pages to the discussion of affinity 
between Dravidian languages and some languages spoken outside 
India and with Harappan.

Chapter 2: Phonology: Descriptive
This chapter begins with the sounds of Proto Dravidian. It also offers 
an explanation for subsequent sound changes in the modern 
Dravidian languages. This is followed by a description of vowels and 
consonants found in different groups within the Dravidian family such 
as South Dravidian I, South Dravidian II, Central Dravidian and North 
Dravidian. The description includes allophonic variations of these 
vowels and consonants. Dialectical variations are also mentioned. 
Some light is thrown on the suprasegmental features. 
Morphophonemic patterns also find a place. The chapter ends with an 
appendix containing the phonemic inventories of individual languages 
with separate tables for vowels and consonants.

Chapter 3: The Writing Systems of the Major Literary Languages
The third chapter is devoted to the description of script systems of 
modern Dravidian languages. Beginning with a brief note on Ashokan 
Brahmi script, the mother of all major Indian scripts, the chapter 
contains a discussion of the evolutionary aspects of the major modern 
Dravidian languages, viz. Telugu, Kannada, Tamil and Malayalam. 
Proto Telugu & Kannada script developed in sixth century AD. It 
continued till fifteenth century AD after which they diverged and 
developed independently. He elaborates on how new symbols were 
innovated and added to the existing Ashokan Brahmi script to 
represent sounds peculiar to Tamil. Out of this adapted script called 
Tamil Brahmi evolved a transitional variety called Vattezuttu. How 
Malayalam and Tamil scripts developed independently is described at 
some length. This is supplemented by a chart containing symbols of 
primary vowels and consonants of each of these two languages as 
well as vowel diacritics added to consonant symbols. The chapter 
ends with a table showing symbols of consonant clusters in these 
languages.

Chapter 4: Phonology: Historical & Comparative
This chapter provides both a historical and a comparative treatment of 
Dravidian phonology. A feature matrix of the consonant sounds of 
Proto-Dravidian is given in terms of which sound change in the 
Dravidian languages can be explained. The morphophonemic rules of 
Proto-Dravidian are elaborated. Every aspect of sound change in 
each language is discussed at length. The author has identified two 
types of sound change and has argued that the entire system of 
sound changes can be attributed to either system-internal pressures 
or typographical motivation.

Chapter 5: Word Formation: Roots, Stems, Formatives, Derivational 
Suffixes and Nominal Compounds
In the fifth chapter the author deals with all the important aspects of 
the formation of different types of words. It begins with Caldwell's 
description of formation of Proto-Dravidian roots. However, the author 
has differed from Caldwell and reconstructed the primary roots as well 
as extended stems for Proto-Dravidian with great insight, He 
hypothesizes that primary derivational suffixes developed from 
inflectional suffixes are incorporated into the stem. He also cites 
empirical evidence in support of his hypothesis from several case 
studies. Stem formatives of both nouns and verbs are discussed at 
length. Derivational suffixes also form a part of the discussion. He 
concludes the chapter with a discussion on the structure and 
composition of compound words in Proto-Dravidian.

Chapter 6: Nominals: Nouns, Pronouns, Numerals and Time and 
Place Adverbs
In the beginning of this chapter, the author focuses on gender-number 
contrasts with reference to demonstrative pronouns. There seem to 
be three dominant types of gender-number distinctions in Dravidian. 
Each has been separately claimed to represent the Proto-Dravidian 
system by different scholars. The author reaffirms his earlier view 
(Krishnamurti 1961) that type II represents Proto-Dravidian. He also 
includes a summary of the arguments that he presented earlier. 
Discussion of gender-number marking in finite verbs and nominal 
derivation is followed by a section on reconstruction of gender-number 
suffixes. The case system is discussed at length including examples of 
case markers in the subgroups of these languages. The pronoun and 
number (cardinal and ordinal) systems are also described. The 
chapter ends with an appendix containing paradigms of nominal 
declensions in some of the Dravidian languages.

Chapter 7: The Verb
In this the longest chapter of the book, the author sheds light on 
various aspects of verb structure in Dravidian. It begins with a note on 
canonical structures of roots which are common for nouns, verbs and 
adjectives. He also sheds light on the morphological aspects of the 
verbal base. The author identifies three main patterns in the formation 
of transitive causative stems and elaborates on them. The chapter 
includes discussion of tense, gender, number and person markers. It 
also deals with finite and nonfinite verbs in different groups of 
Dravidian languages. Concepts of negation and mood also find a 
place. The author argues that the continuous form of tense in 
Dravidian is an independent innovation and no proto-form can be 
reconstructed. A special discussion is made of serial verbs which is a 
peculiar feature of Dravidian. The chapter ends with a note on 
complex predicates and auxiliaries.

Chapter 8: Adjectives, Adverbs and Clitics
The author begins this chapter with a brief summary of how other 
authors have treated adjectives in Dravidian. Then he reconstructs 
the basic adjectives for Proto-Dravidian corresponding to different 
semantic types. He also elaborates on the details of basic and derived 
adjectives in the modern Dravidian. He delves into the etymological 
aspects of adverbs which are generally derived forms, citing examples 
from individual languages. Having reconstructed four clitics for Proto-
Dravidian, the author then elaborates on their corresponding forms in 
modern Dravidian.

Chapter 9: Syntax
In this chapter the author deviates from the norm that he has followed 
throughout the book. There is no reconstruction of Proto-Dravidian 
syntactic forms. He has restricted discussion of syntax to the four 
literary languages. Simple, complex, and compound sentences are 
analyzed highlighting the structural patterns of their constituents 
corresponding to different types. He has established that all the four 
literary languages follow similar syntactic patterns.

Chapter 10: Lexicon
Dravidian lexicon is divided into two groups viz. native and borrowed. 
The loan words come from three distinct sources viz. Indo-Aryan, 
Perso-Arabic and Western languages like English and Portuguese. He 
has explained with illustration how words of Indo-Aryan origin entered 
these languages via Pali & Prakrit rather than from Sanskrit directly. 
The process of nativization of these words in the respective 
languages conforming to their phonological rules is illustrated. The 
borrowing of words from other languages is also discussed. Kannada, 
Telugu and Malayalam have taken borrowing as a natural process. 
But in Tamil there has been a deliberate effort to replace words of 
Sanskrit origin with native words. This chapter also includes a 
discussion of semantic fields and onomatopoeic words.

Chapter 11: Conclusion: A Summary and Overview
The concluding chapter contains a summary of the book and an 
overview of research of Dravidian by previous scholars. The author 
reiterates the arguments for making a new sub-grouping of the 
Dravidian languages based on evidence from phonological as well as 
morphological features. Desiderata, which forms the concluding part 
of this chapter, contains suggestions of viable topics for future 
research in comparative and historical Dravidian.

CRITICAL EVALUATION

The book is undoubtedly a significant contribution to the study of 
historical and comparative aspects of Dravidian languages. It is also 
significant from typological perspective. The book is well organized, 
coherent and highly informative. The author presents an enormous 
data in a systematic way, from minor non-literary languages to the 
major literary ones. In fact, the vast amount of data from minor 
languages adds to the strength of the book. His conclusions, which 
differ from those of other scholars, are well supported by this data. 
Each topic in the book is dealt with utmost detail.

The last chapter containing summary and overview makes it 
particularly user-friendly as it helps the reader to keep track of what 
has been said in previous chapters. The desiderata are especially 
useful for scholars interested in future research in this area.

However, the chapter on syntax is less informative and there is no 
reconstruction of Proto-Dravidian forms. The book would have been 
even more comprehensive if syntax had been dealt with as extensively 
as phonology and morphology.

Nonetheless, the book will serve as a great sourcebook for students, 
scholars, and teachers of linguistics.

REFERENCE

Krishnamurti, Bh. 1961. Telugu Verbal Bases: A Comparative and 
Descriptive Study. UCPL 24, Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of 
California Press. 

ABOUT THE REVIEWER


Basanti Devi received her PhD on 'A Contrastive Study of Assamese 
and Kannada' from University of Mysore, India. She has been 
teaching linguistics to speech and hearing students for the past twenty 
years. In 2003 she was awarded senior fellowship to work 
on 'Representation of Women in Assamese Fiction' by Sahitya 
Akademi, New Delhi. Her research interests are in sociolinguistics, 
psycholinguistics, clinical linguistics, language and gender, and 
literature. Currently she is an associate professor of linguistics at JSS 
Institute of Speech and Hearing, Mysore, India.





-----------------------------------------------------------
LINGUIST List: Vol-17-1541