eto - query
Wayles Browne
ewb2 at CORNELL.EDU
Tue Jul 17 20:30:14 UTC 2001
I was able to find a number of examples by searching for "chto ehto"
in the Tubingen Russian Corpora at
http://www.sfb441.uni-tuebingen.de/b1/korpora.html ,
for instance the following:
Gefunden in Text XGBI0301
à ÍýÍÓÓ ·ÎÓ åÓÌýÓÛ , ÔËÍËÌÛ¯ÂÏÛ Ó·Â ÓÔÓÁýÌËÂ Ë ÛÊ ÚÂÓ
ýÒÒËÚý¯ÂÏÛ ÎÂÚÂÚ¸ ÌËÍýÍ Ì ÔÓÁÊ ,
ÂÏ ... Û ÓÒÓÁÌýÚ¸ , ÚÓ ÚÓ Â¸ ÂÓ ÂÈÒ ÍÎËÍýÚ ÔÂÏ , ÂÓ !
(I kakovo bylo Monaxovu, prikinuvshemu obshchee opozdanie i uze tverdo
rasschityvavshemu vyletet' nikak ne pozzhe, chem... vdrug osoznat',
chto e`to ved' evo rejs vyklikajut pervym, evo!)
Gefunden in Text XGGA0301
èÓÎÛÚÓýÓÓýÎýþ ÓÍý Ë , ÓÌýÍÓ , ÂÂ ÓÎÓ ÓÒÚýýÎýÒ¸ Û ÒÂÍÓË
: ÒËÚýÎÓÒ¸ , ÚÓ ÏÓÎÓÂ ÔÓÒÚÓ ÒÒÓÂ . çÓ
ÓÌË ÓÙËËýθÌÓ ýÁÓ¯ÎËÒ¸ ÂÂÁ ÌÂÒÍÓθÍÓ ÎÂÚ , Ë Ò ÔÓÂÌÛÎÓÒ¸
ÔÓÒΠÚýÍ , ÚÓ ÚÓ ÏÛÊ " ·ÓÒËÎ ÒÂϸ " . ÇÔÓÂÏ ,
ÍÓÌÂÌÓ , ÚÂÔ¸ ÚÛÌÓ ÒÛËÚ¸ , ÍÚÓ ·Î Ôý , ÍÚÓ ËÌÓýÚ .
(Polutoragodovalaja dochka ix, odnako, eshche dolgo ostavalas'
u svekrovi: schitalos', chto molodye prosto v ssore. No
oni oficial'no razoshlis' cherez neskol'ko let, i vse
povernulos' posle tak, chto e`to muzh "brosil sem'ju".
Vprochem, konechno, teper' trudno sudit', kto byl prav, kto
vinovat.)
Gefunden in Text XPLV0201
êýÁ Ì ÓÒÍÂÒÂ̸ ? " èÓÚÓÏ þ ÔÓÌËÏý , ÚÓ ÚÓ þÚÂÎ Ò·ËÎ ÏÂÌþ ÒÓ
ÒÂÚÛ : þ ÛÒίýÎ ÁÛÍ ý·ÓÚ , Ë ÏÌÂ
ÔÓÍýÁýÎÓÒ¸ ÒÚýÌÌÏ , ÚÓ ý·ÓÚýÚ ÓÒÍÂÒÂ̸ , Ë Î˯¸ ÚÓý þ
ÓÒÓÁÌýÎ , ÚÓ ÚÓ þÚÂÎ . çÓ ÚÓ , ÚÓ þÚÂÎ ÌÂ
ÁÌýÂÚ ÓÒÍÂÒÌ ÌÂÈ , ÍýÍ-ÚÓ ÔËÒÚËÎÓ ÏÂÌþ .
(The first instance in:
Potom ja ponimaju, chto e`to djatel sbil menja so schetu:
ja uslyshal zvuk raboty, i mne pokazalos' strannym, chto
rabotajut v voskresen'e, i lish' togda ja soznal, chto e`to
djatel.)
... þ ÔÓÌþÎ , ÚÓ ÚÓ þÚÂÎ ÒÓ ÒÓËÏ ÍýÊÓÌÂÌÏ
ÚÛÓηËÂÏ ÌýÒÚÓËÎ ÏÂÌþ ÚýÍ...
(ja ponjal, chto e`to djatel so svoim kazhdodnevnym trudoljubiem
nastroil menja tak...)
Gefunden in Text XSIS0301
èÓÚÓÏ , ÌýÍÓÌ , ÔÓÌþÎ Ë Î ÒýÏ , ý ÎË Â¯ËÎË , ÚÓ ÚÓ ÓÌË ÂÓ
ÓÔÓÍËÌÛÎË .
(Potom, nakonec, ponjal i leg sam, a ljudi reshili, chto e`to oni ego
oprokinuli.)
à ÚÓθÍÓ ÔÓÚÓÏ ÓÌ ÔÓÌþÎ , ÚÓ ÚÓ Î·Ó¸ ÂÎýÂÚ ÚýÛ ÍÛÒÌÓÈ .
(I tol'ko potom on ponjal, chto e`to ljubov' delaet travu vkusnoj.)
etc.
>Dear SEELANGERS
>I saw a claim recently, in a paper on Yiddish, that Russian sentences
>focused by eto are ungrammatical when embedded.
>Thus: Eto Sasha uvidel Mashu. It is Sasha that saw Masha.
>but allegedly
>*Ja znaju shto eto Sasha uvidel Mashu. I know that it is Sasha that saw Masha.
>I feel that this is not so, but, not being a native speaker, I would like
>to hear the opinion of native speakers of Russian. Also, if anyone can
>point to some nice counterexamples from written language, literature, press
>etc. Finally, the most recent treatment of this in Russian that I read is
>Paducheva, Znachenie i sintakticheskie funkcii slova eto, in Problemy
>strukturnoj lingvistiki 1980, 76-91. I'm sure there must be more recent
>work on this, and I'd be grateful for any reference.
>Many thanks
>Moshe Taube
>
>Moshe Taube
>DeptMoshe TaubeM
>
>-------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Use your web browser to search the archives, control your subscription
> options, and more. Visit and bookmark the SEELANGS Web Interface at:
> http://members.home.net/lists/seelangs/
>-------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Wayles Browne, Assoc. Prof. of Linguistics
Department of Linguistics
Morrill Hall 220, Cornell University
Ithaca, New York 14853, U.S.A.
tel. 607-255-0712 (o), 607-273-3009 (h)
fax 607-255-2044 (write FOR W. BROWNE)
e-mail ewb2 at cornell.edu
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Use your web browser to search the archives, control your subscription
options, and more. Visit and bookmark the SEELANGS Web Interface at:
http://members.home.net/lists/seelangs/
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
More information about the SEELANG
mailing list