Speechwriting and GebaerdenSchrift
stefanwoehrmann at GOOGLEMAIL.COM
Sat Feb 12 21:38:49 UTC 2011
Hello Valerie, hello Fernando and friends of the sw-list,...
after a looooong ride with the bus I returned with lots and lots of very
interesting impressions from a visit to school in Poland.
To share the most important experience first ha Woehrmanns
speechwriting as Valerie calls my invention to standardize movements of
articulation even if performed without any sound (like the German do very
often within their SL-performance, besides mouth-gestic and mimic) works
pretty good for polish spoken language as well. big smile
Second: My deaf students showed such a tremendous pride in the task to
compare German Sign Language to Polish Sign Language and thanks to Valerie
and her incredible ingenious invention these folks sat together at the table
and wrote, and wrote and wrote one sign after the next and the polish deaf
students have had no problem ( ha of course not to identify the first
couple of pictograms as I call SignWriting-graphics as long as the reader
does not know the meaning of the single symbols ... The newcomer just
remembers the whole graphic as a meaningful representation of a sign:
forest, Poland, speech, quiet, Germany, colour, ...
You cannot imagine or well , if you have seen this yourself a couple of
time your know what I am talking about.
The two schools of Germany and Poland are participants in a Comenius
exchange program all over Europe. Our idea is to get informed about each
other, our culture, language, history, background, living conditions ....
school system ...
Well I sat down and thanks to my colleague M. Riemann who is a very skilled
expert if it come down to write GebaerdenSchrift by hand I practiced a lot
to achieve a higher level in handwriting myself- smile.
Now in Poland we got the task to write a given story for children in
Signwriting. There are not that many signs in the Polish dictionary so far
so my colleague at that school and me spent some hours to get a first draft
of the signed Polish version. At this school in Poland they are very much
interested to support deaf children to use SL as a tool to support Spoken
Language acquisition. I could not believe that the symbolset for
speechwriting in Gebaerdenschrift is aleady well established to describe
polish mouth movements pretty sharp. The teacher in Poland showed so much
interest and motivation and asked me almost always to add the whole (!!!)
number of speechwriting-symbols in order to describe the information coming
from the mouth as detailed as possible. - ;-)
It will be a challenge dear Fernando to give it a try whether the
system I developed so far would be sufficient as well to describe the
information coming from the mouth of a signer in Brazil.
Know what I can understand your feelings of enthusiasm. We psychologists
get kind of idea about the doors we will be able to open to our deaf
students if we can offer additional tools that allow them to associate
spoken language with their easy to learn Sign language fundament.
It took me very long many years to improve this Speechwriting system and
the graphics and symbols you refer to are history - big smile. Today we
use a very nice and easy to understand symbol set that is not any more a
mixture of hand and facial expression symbols.
You may contact me privately so that we can discuss what kind of materials I
will be able to offer to you. You can be sure that it will be my pleasure to
support you and to share my knowledge in this field.
The whole matter is a little bit complicated since we have to understand
that there are two completely different symbol sets and ideas.
Mundbildschrift is the notation system invented by me to document that a
given symbol and only this one(!) is to be associated with a given sound
of speech. This system is a wonderful, wonderful very powerful tool to
support deaf students to learn to articulate any (!!!!!) given language
not just German (!) if the sounds of the language in question have been
defined. You can compare this Mundbildschrift Woehrmann´s Speechwriting
to the IPA = One symbol one sound and very easy to read even for very
young children at age 3 or 4 years (!!!!)
The other system is what the deaf student is confronted with all the time:
The guessing-game called lip reading not every symbol has just one
option in the spoken language system. This notation system is not to be
confused with Woehrmann´s Speechwriting ... I call it Mundbilder in
Well what a long message smile . I should stop and wait for your answer.
All the best
Your message gave me goosebumps!
Thank you so very much for calling my attention to Stefan Woehrmann's
amazingly important work!
I felt that sort of thrill running up and down my spinal cord that signals
when I am before something of true importance!
Woehrmann's strategy of using Sutton's SignWriting to write speech...
SpeechWriting... is just brilliant!
Gosh, you guys are awesome! That is precisely what I needed! Wow!
Over the last 20 years my crew and I have documented the cheremic structure
and the morphemic structures of the Libras lexicon, and over the last 12
years we have benefited from SignWriting as a way of writing down those
parameters. Over the last 8 years my crew and I have documented visemis
structure of Portuguese (specially in its correspondence to phonemic and
graphemic structures). We have also created a number of instruments and
documented the parameters of language development of deaf population. During
all that time we had been dreaming of reconciling and articulating the
efforts of two fronts in order to overcome the apparent schizophrenic state
of affairs in deaf education:
Lately, on one hand we had been studying Cued Speech and Visual phonics and
their benefits for literacy acquisition. On the other hand, we had been
planning the systematic study of the benefits of SignWriting for
metalinguistic development and literacy acquisition. Now, your message
simply makes the perfect match between those extremes, fills the gap,
restores the cycle of sanity and progress.
Valerie: Ientered the page you send me. I saw beautiful Irina's picture, and
it just warmed my heart. She was pointing at the SpeechWriting unit and was
emiting the corresponding lalemic unit. So the correspondence
viseme-SpeechWriting was there, beautifully illustrated. (Oh, if we just had
the table of visemes-grapheme-SpeechWriting units with the corresponding
symbol transcription in the International Phonetic Alphabet!!!.) Then,
below, there was a series of six pictures of that handsome blond boy
illustrating 6 visemes-grapheme-SpeechWriting units. Great! That is
precisely the sort of correspondences we need! (But we need the whole table
of visemes-grapheme-SpeechWriting units with the corresponding symbol
transcription in the International Phonetic Alphabet!!!) Then, by clicking
it appears a wonderful table (and he did that back in 2002!) from A to Eu,
along with pictures of visemes! (Oh, Gosh! The only thing mising is the
International Phonetic Alphabet transcription! Just that to make it
we watch the baby crying for his mother: "where is my mother"
Could it be possible to complete that incredible page by adding the
International Phonetic Alphabet transcription?
In the new expanded edition of the Novo Deit-Libras I have written a large
chapter describing a new paradigm for lexical research in Sign languages, as
well as a 100 page chapter describing a new paradigm for
speech-written-signed language research in which I included a section on
SignWriting as a tremendous resource (where I provide references of books,
theses, and site), as well a section on Cued Speech and Visual Phonics
(where I provide references of books, theses, and site). Now I do want to
include a section on SpeechWriting, and I need more sources of references to
cite. I need to provide references to books, theses, chapters, articles, as
well as the site. Therefore I would like to ask Stefan Woehrmann and
Valerie if they have papers, chapters, publications I could cite in our
dictionary in order to help people know of SpeechWriting. I would also like
to ask Stefan and Valerie and other colleagues who know the International
Phonetic Alphabet as well as German whether they could provide the
International Phonetic Alphabet transcription of each viseme depicted in
those pictures in pages such as:
that is, we need at least from spricht A to spricht EU.
The new edition off our NOVO DEIT-LIBRAS is to go to print in 3 weeks, and
it would be so good if I could include as much information as possble on
SpeechWriting. That is why I need references to be able to list and divulge.
It would also be of the utmost importance to have the SpeechWriting units
corresponding to the IPA units, at least in German and English (should there
be one). People do have to know more about it. And we, here in Brazil, have
to adapt SpeechWriting to write down the Portuguese visemes, so as to be
able to use it as a way of writing down Brazilian-Portuguese speech and also
implementing Cued Speech and Visual Phonics in a much improved way.
Som what we can do now to help kids is to (with due credits to you, guys,
inventors of SpeechWriting) use your SpeechWriting to write down the
orofacial patterns of Portuguese! Would you please tell me whether Stefan
Woehrmann has mapped the visemes of the spoken German? Does he have a table
of correspondences among visemes, graphemes, SpeechWriting units,
International Phonetic Alphabet transcriptions?
Stefan Woehrmann: are you there? Can you please send us the table of
correspondences among visemes, graphemes, SpeechWriting units, International
Phonetic Alphabet transcriptions? Along with papers you have written that we
may cite in our papers and chapters and books?
We now need terribly a table of correspondences among visemes, graphemes,
SpeechWriting units, International Phonetic Alphabet transcriptions based on
the International Phonetic Alphabet, so that we might write down each and
every spoken language conceivable. It would be of the utmost importance if
the inventors of the SpeechWriting system could lay down all SpeechWriting
units linked to the International Phonetic Alphabet.
That would allow us to speechwrite each and every language.
The first step would be for Stefan to add the International Phonetic
Alphabet transcription of the visemes illustrated in his pictures, so as to
allow the speechwriting of German.
Stefan, could you please provide the table of SpeechWriting units for the
visemes of German along with IPA transcriptions?
(The first step would be to add the International Phonetic Alphabet
transcription beside each picture.)
Sorry for the enthusiasm. It is invluntary. The culprit is this funny pink
cloud that seems not to go away. What an enduring great feeling! I am
experiencing a state of grace! Inspiration feels just great! Thank you for
that! (I feel 30 years younger and 90 pounds lighter! -hah!)
2011/2/12 Valerie Sutton < <mailto:sutton at signwriting.org>
sutton at signwriting.org>
February 12, 2011
Hello Fernando and everyone!
Thank you for this message...
On Feb 10, 2011, at 9:45 PM, fernando capovilla wrote:
Thank you for your kind message, and for posting the news.
It was fun to see the TV program from Brazil ;-)
I will try to explain briefly what I meant:
Over the last 20 years we have made strong efforts to establish research &
development programs for creating valid and standardized batteries for
assessing of a wide range of language competences. After examining more than
10,000 deaf students for more than 25 hours each, we have mapped parameters
of development of competences such as alphabetical reading & spelling,
speechreading skill and vocabulary, sign comprehension and expression,
cheremic awareness, morphemic awareness, working memory, etc.
What a huge undertaking! ...
We have used those instruments and parameters to compare the effects of a
number of variables such as school placement, language used as vehicle for
teaching, literacy acquisition methods and materials, etc. We have
discovered the best time schedule for literacy acquisition and articulation
between special education and mainstreaming, and we are working on public
policies of education based on that scientific evidence.
Changing public policies, I bet, must be very hard indeed... This is such
important work for Deaf education...
We have covered a wide range of subjects and fields, ranging all the way
from the transparent to the profound. In order to help deaf kids learn
Portuguese we have used all strategies conceivable, including taking
advantage of the degree of transparency in the orofacial-graphemic
correspondences in spoken and written Portuguese for helping
cochlear-implanted deaf kids, all the way to taking advantage of the deep
morphemic structure correspondences between Libras and Portuguese for
helping congenital deaf kid read and spell. We have come across beautifully
significant effects that have been quite encouraging.
Very impressive, Fernando - just setting up the project must be a huge job,
as well as then collecting all the data and so forth -
May I mention another way to reach Deaf kids who need to learn spoken
languages?... Stefan Woehrmann at the Osnabruck School for the Deaf in
Osnabruck, Germany, is a teacher of Deaf children, many of whom have
cochlear implants... Stefan has helped Deaf students learn to speak, read
and write better spoken language using his own creative development...in
German it is called Mundbildschrift, and in English we call it Woehrmann's
SpeechWriting, where the symbols for mouth movements in SignWriting, have
been expanded to write spoken German...so an entire spoken language sentence
can be written in SpeechWriting, showing the Deaf student how the mouth
moves when pronouncing words, in a standardized way...and it works! Stefan's
students are not only reading and understanding the German spoken language
better than other Deaf students who do not have this tool, but their actual
speech is improving as well... I think Stefan's work is really a new
contribution to Deaf education, that many teachers do not realize is there
I realize that SpeechWriting for spoken Portuguese may not be practical in
Brazil right now, but nonetheless, writing the way the mouth moves while
speaking can also have benefit for Deaf education, so I wanted to share that
working theory with you - it could be developed specifically for the
Portuguese spoken language if you ever know of someone who is interested
working on that project...
Also, we have documented thousands of fascinating phenomena, such as
cheremic paralexias and cheremic paragrafias similar to those first
described originally by Klina & Bellugi's The signs of language; and
Poizner, Klima & Bellugi's What the hands reveal about the brain. Now we are
finally getting close to the point we started dreaming of back in 1998, when
we first found out about SignWriting while struggling with HamNoSys and
Stokoe Notation System.
I feel very honored to work with you, and that SignWriting is useful...
We are finally getting close to be able to start addressing the questions
pertaining the analysis and mapping the effects of SW upon cognition and
language. We first had to set a number of parameters straight so as to know
precisely where we are. We have made encouraging progress in that regard. We
still have to finish the treatise, the compendium, the new sign-retrieval
system based on cheremes, and the 6 remaining volumes of the encyclopedia
first, though. Yet, we are confident we will manage to succeed in including
a research lprogram devoted to assessing the effects of a SW instruction
program by 2012. We will keep on working. Thank you very much for your kind
enduring support. We have learned a lot from you. Best warm wishes,
I am sooo happy to know about your plans to test the use of SignWriting with
Deaf students by 2012...THANK YOU for your hard work you have already done,
teaching your Deaf staff SignWriting, and writing so many signs in the books
you have already published....Just looking at all the signs is almost
overwhelming, there are so many written already...I am quite impressed with
the sheer number of written signs you have - your Deaf staff has been busy!
I will continue to teach how I edit signs on this SW List, not only based on
your beautiful book, Novo Diet-Libras, but also based on other projects. I
will continue to post these lessons on this List, and when time permits
(grin), I will also post the instruction on the web, so everyone can refer
to the lessons anytime...so maybe by 2012 you will have more materials to
work with for your research on SignWriting...
Meanwhile, remember to look at this area on the web from time to time:
<http://www.signwriting.org/lessons> http://www.SignWriting.org/lessons -
and thanks once again, Fernando!
2011/2/11 Valerie Sutton < <mailto:sutton at signwriting.org>
sutton at signwriting.org>
February 10, 2011
Please watch this video:
Professor Fernando Capovilla is in the second half of the TV program...so
wait through the beginning, and in the second segment you will meet
Fernando, telling the world about the Novo-Deit Libras Dictionary...and
although my understanding of Portuguese is minimal (smile ;-) I noticed that
SignWriting is mentioned when Fernando opens the dictionary and points to
the SignWriting - it looked very nice!
An enjoyable program - Val ;-)
PS. I am interested in your research project you mention below,
Fernando...thank you for a systematic study of SignWriting - I had better
get back to my lessons and provide you all with good materials....we have
some new textbooks to share...
On Feb 8, 2011, at 8:49 PM, fernando capovilla wrote:
We are working on your great lessons. Thank you very much.
The 2nd part (2min 26 sec) of this video below talks about our Dic and
SignWriting (4min). It was aired in national public television.
I am coordinating a research project that is to include systematic study of
We keep on studying. Thank you very much for your kind generous help.
Thank you very much. Best warm regards,
Fernando C. Capovilla, PhD
Instituto de Psicologia, USP
Coord Lab Neuropsicolinguística Cognitiva Experimental, IP-Usp
Av. Prof. Mello de Morais 1721
São Paulo, SP, 05508-030
<mailto:fcapovilla3 at gmail.com> fcapovilla3 at gmail.com
visite-nos: <http://lanceusp.hdfree.com.br/> http://lanceusp.hdfree.com.br/
veja nossos novos livros em: <http://lanceusp.hdfree.com.br/livros.html>
assista à entrevista concedida à TV Cultura sobre dislexia:
SignWriting List moderator
<mailto:sutton at signwriting.org> sutton at signwriting.org
Post Messages to the SignWriting List:
<mailto:sw-l at listserv.valenciacc.edu> sw-l at listserv.valenciacc.edu
SignWriting List Archives & Home Page
Join, Leave or Change How You Receive SW List Messages
Fernando C. Capovilla, PhD
Professor Associado, Instituto de Psicologia, USP
Coord Lab Neuropsicolinguística Cognitiva Experimental, IP-Usp
Av. Prof. Mello de Morais 1721, São Paulo, SP, 05508-030
email: <mailto:fcapovilla3 at gmail.com> fcapovilla3 at gmail.com
Veja nossos novos livros (sobre linguagem oral, escrita e de sinais), e
baixe alguns, de: <http://lanceusp.hdfree.com.br/livros.html>
Baixe artigos (sobre linguagem oral, escrita e de sinais) de:
Baixe capítulos (sobre linguagem oral, escrita e de sinais) de:
Assista à entrevista concedida à TV Cultura sobre dislexia:
Veja citação no Wikipedia pelo trabalho com escrita de sinais de Libras em
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Sw-l