99.44% pure
RonButters at AOL.COM
RonButters at AOL.COM
Sat Dec 23 23:22:51 UTC 2006
>
>
Hmmmmm, the math would seem to be pretty simple. If you have 100 pounds of
ivory soap and it contains .56% impurity, that would amount to 100 x .0056, or
.56 pounds or 4.48 ounces. In an 8-ounce bar of soap, tht would amount to .0224
ounces. So the "once molecule for a vbar of soap the size of the distance
between the sun and Jupiter seems to be seriously in error. I'm not sure what
math Paige was using--maybe Paige can elaborate?
Of course the claims are puffery, even so. And if you think about it, who
wants .0224 ounces of impurtity in her hand soap? What if it is a highly toxic
radioactive substance? Drool from the soap-maker's lips? Dead skin from the
soapmaker's unwashed hand? Roach droppings? Mascara? An eyelash? And is each vbar
of soap 99.44% puire, or is that just every ton of soap that comes out of the
factory? If each ton contains one dead mouse chpped up and pureed and
distributed in the first 500 bars, and the remaining bars are correspondingly "pure"
(enough to make the average come out at 99.44% for the whole ton) does that
count?
One of my mother's sayings was, "Well, they say we all eat a peck of dirt in
our lives." Did she make this up, or have others heard it as well?
>
> "hpst at earthlink.net" <hpst at EARTHLINK.NET> wrote:
> ---------------------- Information from the mail header
> -----------------------
> Sender: American Dialect Society
> Poster: "hpst at earthlink.net"
> Subject: Re: 99.44% pure
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
> --
>
> Allison,
>
> My friend James "The Amazing" Randi once asked a chemist about the claim on
> a homeopathic remedy what x% pure meant.
>
> His friend replied that it meant that if you had a ball of pure water which
> extended from the sun to as I recall the orbit of Jupiter only one molecule
> of any other substance could exist.
>
> I've done some of the math on this, and Randi's friend was totally correct.
>
> Bullshit is bullshit and if you look at the labels on some homeopathic
> remedies their claims are physically impossible.
>
> Page Stephens
>
>
------------------------------------------------------------
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org
More information about the Ads-l
mailing list