Illinois bans male pronoun

Thu Jan 4 19:45:46 UTC 2007

     I'm not surprised that the "personhole" (for "manhole") story doesn't appear on Snopes.  I do remember that at the time of the personhole/manhole incident a reporter checked with a member of the city council which produced the change, and the council member did not see any humor in the matter; the council was simply try its best to comply with the regulation about avoiding gender-specific language..  This change was, of course, being regarded nationwide (however briefly) as political correctness run amok.
      Now, whether it's possible at this late date to unearth the newspaper articles with the personhole/manhole story remains to be seen.

Gerald Cohen

________________________________

From: American Dialect Society on behalf of Arnold M. Zwicky
Sent: Thu 1/4/2007 1:25 PM
To: ADS-L at LISTSERV.UGA.EDU
Subject: Re: Illinois bans male pronoun

On Jan 4, 2007, at 10:34 AM, Joel S. Berson wrote:

> Have you looked at the urban legends sites, like Snopes?
>
> Joel
>
> At 1/4/2007 10:54 AM, you wrote:
> does anyone have credible specifics for this story?  i suspect that
>> the whole thing is a fabrication.
>>
>> the google hits for "personhole" suggest that it was, as one writer
>> said, a "satiric exaggeration".  you can find cites, but they all
>> seem snarky rather than serious.
>>
>> arnold

nothing on snopes.  a search for {"urban legend" personhole} pulled
up only one possibly relevant item, the .sig for a regular poster to
the feministsf (feminist SF) mailing list:

"Personhole is not an acceptable de-sexed word." Shirley Dean, council
person from the Berkeley (California) City Council, explaining why the
Council changed the wording in a sewer equipment request, back to
manhole
cover

(Shirley Dean was mayor of Berkeley 1994-2002.)  this quote appears
in a fair number of other places.  some have "council person", some
"councilperson", some "councilmember", but otherwise the quotations
are almost exactly the same.  one site has it in a collection of
quotations from women in the year 2000.

one writer attributes the expression to a female mayor, but in
Sacramento rather than Berkeley:

That could apply to so many places in Kalifornicate! San Jose is my
leading candidate, along with Sacramento (FMR Mayor Anne Rudin's
"Personhole covers" anyone?), and of course, San Frankornhole!
  http://www.theothersideofkim.com/index.php/forums/viewthread/15/

then in a listing of feminist books for sale used i found a reference
to "the great 'personhole cover' debate":

Thom, Mary, editor
Letters to Ms. 1972-1987 Introduction by Gloria Steinem. Afterword by
Eva Moseley
Publisher: Henry Holt, NY [1987].
'First Edition.' xix, 264 p.; dj; fine. Includes Sex: Whose
Revolution Was It?; Men: Love, Marriage, and Just Friends; Parenting:
Bringing Up 'Free' Children; There's No Divorce Between Mothers and
Daughters; Small and Momentous Changes in Everyday Life; The
Workplace Revolution; Woman's Body, Woman's Mind; Language: The Great
'Personhole Cover' Debate; Up Against the Institution; You Can't Win
Them All; Or, Critics (and Crackpots) Take On Ms.; Milestones:
Readers Live Fifteen Years of History.

on the other hand, Sara Mills has written about "personhole cover" in
several places as an example of a media-invented term.  for example,
in "Third Wave Feminist Linguistics and the Analysis of Sexism":

To clarify, "political correctness" is often seen as an excessive
concern for the sensibilities of minority groups (women, the
disabled, lesbians and Black people) which is manifested in  a set of
media-invented absurd, terms, (such as `vertically challenged'
instead of `short' ; `follically challenged' for `bald' ; `personhole
cover' instead of  `manhole/inspection cover') which no anti-sexist
or anti-racist campaigners have argued should be adopted.  These are
often  listed alongside  `Ms'  and `chairperson'  which feminists
have campaigned to be adopted.
   http://extra.shu.ac.uk/daol/articles/open/2003/001/mills2003001-
paper.html

arnold

------------------------------------------------------------
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org <http://www.americandialect.org/> 

------------------------------------------------------------
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org