Indian English

Fri Sep 21 12:32:22 UTC 2007

Both Binoo John and the anonymous author of the article (quoted below) seem not to have heard of "Hobson-Jobson", a well-known reference work (e.g., it is cited in MWCD10) on "Anglo-Indian".  Hobson-Jobson, originally published in 1886, contains over TWO THOUSAND entries, which makes Binoo John look like an ignoramus.

Hobson-Jobson is available on-line at http://dsal.uchicago.edu/dictionaries/hobsonjobson/

(Gee, I didn't know Salikoko Mufwene had a computer named after him.)

Here is its on-line entry for "khaki"

1. KHAKEE, vulgarly KHARKI, KHARKEE: (page 478)
ed. 1858, p. 130. [The Khadir Cup is one of the chief racing trophies open to pig-stickers in upper India.] ,_vulgarly_KHARKI,_KHARKEE"> KHAKEE, vulgarly KHARKI, KHARKEE , s. or adj. Hind. khākī, 'dusty or dust-coloured,' from Pers. khāk, 'earth,' or 'dust'; applied to a light drab or chocolate-coloured cloth. This was the colour of the uniform worn by some of the Punjab regiments at the siege of Delhi, and became very popular in the army generally during the campaigns

2. KHAKEE, vulgarly KHARKI, KHARKEE: (page 478)
be entirely of Khakee."-- Madras Govt. Order, Feb. 18, quoted in Calcutta Rev. ciii. 407. [1862.-- "Kharkee does not catch in brambles so much as other stuffs."-- Brinckman, Rifle in Cashmere, 136.] 1878.-- "The Amir, we may mention, wore a khaki suit, edged with gold, and the well-known Herati cap."-- Sat. Review, Nov. 30, 683. [1899.-- "The batteries to be painted with the Kirkee colour, which being similar to the roads of the country, will render the vehicles invisible."-- Times, July 12.

3. KHAKEE, vulgarly KHARKI, KHARKEE: (page 478)
Sat. Review, Nov. 30, 683. [1899.-- "The batteries to be painted with the Kirkee colour, which being similar to the roads of the country, will render the vehicles invisible."-- Times, July 12. [1890-91.-- The newspapers have constant references to a khaki election, that is an election started on a war policy, and the War Loan for the Transvaal Campaign has been known as "khakis."] Recent military operations have led to the general introduction of khaki as the service uniform. Something like this has

4. KHAKEE, vulgarly KHARKI, KHARKEE: (page 479)
The newspapers have constant references to a khaki election, that is an election started on a war policy, and the War Loan for the Transvaal Campaign has been known as "khakis."] Recent military operations have led to the general introduction of khaki as the service uniform. Something like this has been used in the East for clothing from a very early time:- [1611.-- "See if you can get me a piece of very fine brown calico to make me clothes." -- Danvers, Letters, i. 109.]

The pathetic Binoo John article follows:
<quote>
          It has taken decades of struggle, but more than half a century after the British departed from India, standard English has finally followed.
                   Entry From Backside Only

  Young and educated Indians regard the desire to speak English as it is spoken in England as a silly hang-up from a bygone era. Homegrown idiosyncrasies have worked their way into the mainstream to such an extent that only fanatical purists question their usage.

Now Penguin, the quintessentially British publishing house, has put the nearest thing to an official imprimatur on the result by producing a collection of some of the most colourful phrases in use - in effect a dictionary of what might be called "Indlish".
  Its title, Entry From Backside Only, refers to a phrase commonly used on signposts to indicate the rear entrance of a building. Binoo John, the author, said young Indians had embraced the variant of the language as a charming offspring of the mingling of English and Hindi, rather than an embarrassing mongrel.
  "Economic prosperity has changed attitudes towards Indian English," said Mr John. "Having jobs and incomes, and being noticed by the rest of the world, have made Indians confident - and the same confidence has attached itself to their English."
  The 50-year-old journalist said he was inspired by the success of Lynn Truss's guide to punctuation, Eats, Shoots & Leaves, and by years of reading newspaper reports of politicians "air-dashing" to a destination, "issueless" couples (those without children) and people "preponing" (bringing forward) meetings.

  But such phrases are entrenched. A driver, when asked what he does, may refer to his occupation as "drivery". He keeps his "stepney" (spare tyre) in the "dicky" (boot).
  Housemaids on their way to buy vegetables tell their employers they are going "marketing". Receptionists ask callers, "What is your good name?" before informing them that the boss has gone "out of station" (out of town) with his "cousin-brother" (male cousin). A government official urged farmers in Rajasthan to grow "herbs in their backsides" (backyards).
  "Everyone is breaking the rules and being creative about how to use English," said Rukmini Bhaya Nair, a professor of English at the Indian Institute of Technology in Delhi. "It is finally being claimed by Indians as their own, instead of a relic of the Raj."
  Despite the changes, English has enjoyed phenomenal popularity over the past few decades. Good English can transform the lives of the impoverished - leading to a better job, a rich spouse, a more exciting social life, and social superiority.
  Couples who live on less than 25p a day will skip a meal to pay for their children to attend a school where they will be taught in English. The English-teaching industry is estimated to be worth £150 million.
  For the better off, fluent English and a "good" accent convey status faster than titles, names, addresses or offshore bank accounts.
  A 1997 survey by India Today magazine estimated that about a third of the country's population of more than one billion could carry on a conversation in English.
  The columnist Anjali Puri said pride in Indian English also stemmed from the success of writers such as Arundhati Roy, Vikram Seth and Salman Rushdie: "These writers have used English to portray Indian reality and it has given people the confidence to try out new words and play around with the language without being scared about whether they are correct."
  If spoken English can be curious, the written form is even more so. In railway offices, a standard opening line in correspondence is: "Dear Sir, with reference to your above see my below."
  As in Britain, employers complain that the standard of English is so abysmal that recruits cannot write a sentence without three grammatical mistakes. One call centre executive in Bombay said a new recruit wrote an email that began: "I am in well here and hope you are also in the same well."
  A glossary of the latest lingo as spoken on the streets of India
  Dear sir, with reference to your above see my below - popular opening line in official letters.
  Teachress - a female teacher.
  Timepass - a trivial activity that passes the time.
  She freaked out last night - she had a good time.
  Your lyrical missive has enveloped me in the sweet fragrance of our love - from a book advising lovers on how to write to girlfriends.
  How often do you take sex? - question from doctor to patient.
  Pritam Singh has left for his heavenly above - a death notice.
  Hue and Cry notice - title of police missing person newspaper advertisement.
  Don't do nuisance in public - government admonition against urinating in public </quote>

James A. Landau
Test Engineer
Northrop-Grumman Information Technology
8025 Black Horse Pike, Suite 300
West Atlantic City  NJ  08232  USA
~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^
AXCDT KUHDU MBZCU UUHSW KYOJK
FVQBC LPVLC ZNNJF YKQB
^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^~^

------------------------------------------------------------
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org