Celtic Germanic relationship
Ray Hendon
rayhendon at satx.rr.com
Fri Nov 24 19:02:26 UTC 2000
I am confused about the linguistic relationship, if any, between Celt and
German. I think I read somewhere that Celtic was an Italic language, and that
German was a daughter language of Celtic, developing after Celtic became
distinguished from other Italic languages.
Also, if there is a relationship, has anything of a time-line been established
for the periods of transition?
[ Moderator's comment:
The traditional Indo-European family tree (to use the model most familiar to
non-specialists) has Germanic, Celtic, and Italic as three separate branches.
Some, but by no means all, Indo-Europeanists believe that the Italic and
Celtic branches should be considered to form a sub-unit of the tree, based on
certain morphological developments; this branch is called Italo-Celtic.
The Germanic branch shares some developments and vocabulary with Italic and
Celtic, and others with Balto-Slavic. This has recently led a few people to
posit an early separation of Germanic from the rest of the family (but from
a branch that later led to Balto-Slavic), then massive influence from Celtic
and Italic.
No authoritative Indo-Europeanist to my knowledge has suggested the branch
structure you outline.
--rma ]
More information about the Indo-european
mailing list