Montana: Pardons Granted 88 Years After Crimes of Sedition

Harold F. Schiffman haroldfs at
Wed May 3 18:40:35 UTC 2006

>>From the NYTimes, May 3, 2006

Pardons Granted 88 Years After Crimes of Sedition

HELENA, Mont., May 2 When Steve Milch found out recently that his
great-grandfather, an immigrant from Bavaria, had been convicted of
sedition in Montana during World War I, he was taken aback. It was
something no one in the family had ever talked about. For the past 88
years, a lot of secrets have been kept in Montana families, especially
those of German descent, about a flurry of wartime sedition prosecutions
in 1918, when public sentiment against Germany was at a feverish pitch.
Seventy-nine Montanans were convicted under the state law, considered
among the harshest in the country, for speaking out in ways deemed
critical of the United States. In one instance, a traveling wine and
brandy salesman was sentenced to 7 to 20 years in prison for calling
wartime food regulations a "big joke."

But the silence and for some families, the shame has ended. The
convictions will be undone on Wednesday when Gov. Brian Schweitzer, a
descendant of ethnic Germans who migrated here from Russia in 1909,
posthumously pardons 75 men and three women. One man was pardoned shortly
after the war. Forty-one of those convicted, including one woman, went to
prison on sentences from 1 to 20 years and paid fines from $200 to
$20,000. "I'm going to say what Gov. Sam Stewart should have said," Mr.
Schweitzer said, referring to the man who signed the sedition legislation
into law in 1918. "I'm sorry, forgive me, and God bless America, because
we can criticize our government."

Dozens of relatives of the convicted seditionists will be at the State
Capitol to witness the signing of the pardons, with some traveling from as
far as Florida. Marie Van Middlesworth, the 90-year-old daughter of one of
those convicted, Fay Rumsey, will be coming from Medford, Ore. She was
among 12 children put up for adoption when the family farm failed after
her father was imprisoned. Mr. Milch said the official acknowledgment,
even after so many years, offered comfort and closure to the families.
"The whole Milch clan is appreciative of making things right," he said.
The pardon ceremony is a result of a book by Clemens P. Work, director of
graduate studies at the University of Montana School of Journalism, called
"Darkest Before Dawn: Sedition and Free Speech in the American West"
(University of New Mexico Press, 2005). The book chronicled a contentious
period in Montana history when people were convicted and jailed for
voicing their opinion about the war.

"It was an ugly time," Mr. Work said.

After reading the book, Jeffrey Renz, a law professor at the University of
Montana, asked Mr. Work what he intended to do about the convictions. Mr.
Work had no plans, he said, "but I told them in my box of dreams I hoped
these people would be exonerated." Professor Renz's students took the
project on as part of a criminal law clinic. Some contacted family members
of the convicted seditionists, and others researched the law, leading to a
petition for pardon being sent to the governor last month. The sedition
law, which made it a crime to say or publish anything "disloyal, profane,
violent, scurrilous, contemptuous or abusive" about the government,
soldiers or the American flag, was unanimously passed by the Legislature
in February 1918. It expired when the war ended, Mr. Work said.

During that time, though Germans were the largest ethnic group in Montana,
it was also illegal to speak German, and books written in it were banned.
Local groups called third-degree committees were formed to ferret out
people not supportive of the war, especially those who did not buy Liberty
Bonds. "They leaned on people to ante up and buy bonds, and if they
didn't, they were disloyal and considered pro-German," Mr. Work said.
Farida Briner said she was told that a committee showed up at her father's
farm. "They threatened to hang him and tar and feather him," Ms. Briner
said. Her father, Herman Bausch, was taken to town, interrogated and later
convicted. He spent two years in prison. Officials encouraged neighbor to
inform on neighbor, and one person's accusation was often enough for an

Mr. Milch's great-grandfather, John Milch, was turned in by an undercover
agent named Eberhard Von Waldru, who was working for the prosecutor in
Helena, the state capital. Mr. Von Waldru went into a German beer hall and
drew out people's feelings on the war. His testimony was used against Mr.
Milch; his brother, Joseph; and six other men. All were convicted, and
four went to prison. John Milch was sentenced to three to six years, but
the law had expired by the time he was to begin serving his term. Joseph
was fined $1,800. Steve Milch said that although his family was not aware
of the arrest, they did know about the anti-German sentiment of the time.
"There was a story that a mob of people was going around asking Germans to
kiss the flag," Mr. Milch said. "My great-grandfather told them he didn't
kiss anybody's flag, whether it was American or German."

Mr. Milch also had another surprise in store. He discovered that the
great-grandfather of another lawyer in his firm was the Helena prosecutor
who hired Mr. Von Waldru. "His great-grandfather prosecuted my
great-grandfather," Mr. Milch said. Mr. Work, who was conducting research
for the book when the Sept. 11 attacks occurred, said he had found the
similarities between 2001 and 1918 to be eerie. "The hair on the back of
my neck stood up," Mr. Work said. "The rhetoric was so similar, from the
demonization of the enemy to saying 'either you're with us or against us'
to the hasty passage of laws." Twenty-seven states had sedition laws
during World War I. Montana's became the template for a federal law,
enacted by Congress later in 1918. More than 30 Montanans were arrested
under the federal law, though none were convicted, according to the
Montana Sedition Project, which Mr. Work directs.

Mr. Work and other historians believe that the harshness of the Montana
law was influenced by the Anaconda Copper Mining Company, which dominated
the state economically and viewed the law as a way to deal with labor
unrest. Many of those charged with sedition were immigrant laborers. But
blame should also be laid at the feet of Governor Stewart, Mr. Work said.
"In the last 100 days of his term, he commuted 50 sentences, including 13
murderers and 7 rapists," he said, "but not a single seditionist."

[moderator's note: Laws and edicts making it illegal to speak German in
the US during World War II were overturned by the US Supreme Court in the
case of Meyer v. Nebraska, on June 4, 1923.]

More information about the Lgpolicy-list mailing list