Maryland: Town Looks to Make English Official Language

Harold F. Schiffman haroldfs at
Sat Nov 4 16:33:43 UTC 2006

No. Md. Town Looks to Make English Official Language

Posted on November 03, 2006:

WASHINGTON - Taneytown, a small city in Carroll County three miles from
Pennsylvania, will consider a proposal to make English its official
language at a City Council workshop Wednesday. The proposal comes on the
heels of a similar law newly passed by Hazleton, Pa., that's gaining
national attention. Hazleton put teeth into that law with another that was
recently suspended by the courts: to fine and possibly take permits from
landlords who housed illegal immigrants and businesses that hired them.
The Taneytown resolution, introduced in August by Councilman Paul L.
Chamberlain Jr., would amend the city's charter and create the English
Language Unity Ordinance, mandating that all government business be
conducted in English.

The council will hold a public hearing on the matter Wednesday before
voting on it as early as next Monday, Chamberlain said. "This is America,"
Chamberlain said. "You don't see the Declaration of Independence written
in any other language, do you?" The ordinance would not conflict with
state and federal laws requiring that the city provide interpreters as
needed, nor would there be a penalty for breaking it, Chamberlain said. If
someone got up at a City Council meeting and spoke Spanish, the most that
would happen is "they wouldn't be understood," he said.

In July, before introducing the resolution, Chamberlain knocked on more
than 500 doors and asked residents whether they thought English should be
the language of Taneytown, he said. "Eight out of 10 people already
thought it was, and they were shocked to hear that that's not the way it
was," he said. The informal poll found widespread support for the policy,
Chamberlain said.

"The people in the city of Taneytown, as well as the mayor and the
council, realize that not only the city of Taneytown, the state, the
United States of America, was founded on a diverse group of people," he
said. "In order for us to communicate with each other, we need to have a
common language, and with a common language, you bring communities
together instead of segregating it." One voice was particularly
influential -- that of Chamberlain's friend, who had a son killed in a
truck accident by a Spanish-speaking driver who could not communicate with
the 911 dispatcher. "That stuff, you know, it shouldn't happen,"
Chamberlain said.

The accident, however, was in Frederick County. Chamberlain said he has
not encountered anyone in Taneytown who cannot speak English, but other
residents have told him they have. Of the 5,128 people who live in the
city, 4,923 are white, said Matthew Simmont, planning manager for the
Carroll County Bureau of Comprehensive Planning. Hispanics are counted in
the "other races" category, a total of 32 people. The county does not keep
data on how many are immigrants or speak another language, he said.
Taneytown does not keep population data at all. The city has never dealt
with anyone needing to use a language other than English for government
business, said Councilman James L. McCarron Jr., who opposes the measure.

"I think that all of the stir that Councilman Chamberlain has caused with
this is an effort to drag attention to an issue that doesn't make any
difference to anybody," McCarron said. Taneytown seemed to be following
the Hazleton model, McCarron said, adding he would not support similar
enforcement measures. "I think it would be a natural lead-in to something
like that," he said.  "I don't think it's an issue that makes sense for a
local government to deal with."


N.b.: Listing on the lgpolicy-list is merely intended as a service to its members
and implies neither approval, confirmation nor agreement by the owner or sponsor of
the list as to the veracity of a message's contents. Members who disagree with a
message are encouraged to post a rebuttal.


More information about the Lgpolicy-list mailing list