California: U.S. Asians drawn to life in Irvine
Harold F. Schiffman
haroldfs at ccat.sas.upenn.edu
Mon Oct 30 13:42:23 UTC 2006
U.S. Asians drawn to life in Irvine Good schools, low crime rates,
well-paying jobs lure many, especially Chinese Americans.
By David Kelly
Times Staff Writer
October 29, 2006
In the world of highly manicured Orange County communities, few are
polished to the luster of Irvine. The master-planned, upscale city of
cookie-cutter homes and broad boulevards looks every inch the stereotype
of suburban living orderly, safe and homogenous. Yet just beneath the
surface lies another Irvine, one of Buddhist temples and teahouses, a city
with bustling Chinese markets and a university where nearly half the
students are Asian. Once the epitome of conservative, white suburbia,
Irvine is now a place where a person can spend a lifetime never having to
speak English. "I used to think I would retire someday and move to
Chinatown," said Yvonne Wang, who moved to Irvine from New Jersey in 1994.
"Now Irvine is like Chinatown."
Attracted by good schools, low crime and well-paying jobs, Irvine has
become a destination for Asian American professionals, especially Chinese
Americans. It's home to one of the country's biggest Chinese language
schools, the largest Buddhist temple and monastery in Orange County, a
Chinese orchestra and clubs for artists, students and senior citizens.
More Chinese Americans live in Irvine than any other city in the county.
"A lot came in the last decade. The education system has clearly been a
magnet; people don't end up living here by accident," said Irvine Mayor
Beth Krom. "We are a Pacific Rim community, so it's natural to see more
Asian people." According to U.S. census estimates, 36.7% of Irvine's
185,000 residents are Asian American. Of that, 21,757 are Chinese, up from
14,973 in 2000. Koreans, Vietnamese and Japanese constitute most of the
remaining Asian Americans. Irvine schools, where classrooms are often
heavily Chinese American, have become among the most competitive in the
"I have heard parents say they don't want to send their kids here because
they aren't high achievers," said Jung Kang, who teaches Chinese at
University High School. "The students are very competitive, but that is an
incentive for others to do better." Yet despite the heavy influx of
Chinese, there is no Chinatown or strictly Chinese neighborhoods. Such
enclaves are more often found in lower-income immigrant areas, places that
don't exist in Irvine. New arrivals here tend to be doctors, lawyers,
engineers and academics with the language skills and money that many
traditional immigrants don't have. And they are catered to in typical
Orange County fashion, with neatly kept shopping centers and strip malls.
The largest is Culver Plaza, home to Chinese banks, restaurants, tea shops
and the sprawling 99 Ranch Market, which carries pickled lettuce, quail
eggs, live catfish and moon cakes.
For culture, Chinese plays and operas are performed at the Irvine Barclay
Theater. Nancy Cheng, 75, a teacher and nurse, came to Irvine from Villa
Park because she was constantly attending Chinese functions here. "I never
spoke so much Chinese in my life until I moved to Irvine," she said. The
rapid transformation of the town from a predominantly white enclave to an
increasingly Asian one can startle even the Chinese Americans. "I came
from San Bernardino, where I was the only Chinese girl in my school," said
Belinda Vong, a member of UC Irvine's Chinese Assn. "I felt special. Not
anymore." Kevin Lee is president of the association. He said UCI, which is
40% Asian, is often referred to as University of Chinese Immigrants.
"When you leave Irvine, it hits you that this is really a bubble," he
said. "A lot of Asians here take their culture for granted." Not those who
came first. They remember when there were only a handful of Chinese
Americans, when there were no clubs, when buying ingredients for dinner
meant driving to Los Angeles and the idea of staging a Chinese opera was
simply unthinkable. "Ten years ago there was not one Chinese store. When I
first came there were a few, mostly Taiwanese, residents. China had not
opened up yet," said Jimmy Ma, a leader in the Chinese American
community. "The big reason people came was because of the schools. Chinese
stress education. That's how we compete."
Ma and others rented high school classrooms for a Chinese language school.
When the rent was raised, they decided to build their own facility. After
years of planning, the $12-million, 44,000-square-foot South Coast Chinese
Cultural Center opened in April. The center's Chinese school now has more
than 1,000 students. It also offers Japanese and Korean language classes,
along with Chinese dance, art, basketball and badminton courts. Students
can also get academic tutoring and SAT preparation. "We want our children
to combine the good part of both cultures Chinese and American," said Joy
Chao, who runs after-school programs at the center.
The school system has had to adapt to Asian immigrants. They have hired
Chinese, Korean and Japanese-speaking staff. They hold regular meetings
with parents to explain how the schools operate. Often, educators say,
parents are keenly interested in what sort of academic performance is
required to get their students into Harvard, Yale or Stanford. "People
talk about culture and they focus on the exterior, superficial things like
food and festivals, but it's really about a person's worldview," said
Melodee Zamudio, who coordinates language programs for the Irvine school
district. "Many of these kids come from a culture where education is such
a precious gift, and you bring honor to the family by studying hard." At
University High, 41% of the students are Asian American, the vast majority
Chinese Americans, said assistant principal Chuck Keith. The Academic
Performance Index is 891, putting it among the top 2% in the state.
"I think the Asian family is a factor in that score," Keith said. "I think
it is part of the culture of our school and I see kids rise to meet those
expectations." Asian American students admit there is pressure to perform
academically, though some say it's easier here than where they came from.
"My parents are very serious about school. They don't push extracurricular
activities," said Charles Jawa, 16. "If I want to do it, fine, but
studying comes first." Jacob Chen, 11, moved from Taiwan three years ago.
"It's much better here than Taiwan," he said. "In Taiwan they give you
four times as much homework."
Some Chinese Americans privately complain that other parents ask them what
grades their children get or what college they will attend. Others send
their children to schools with fewer Chinese students, hoping it will be
less competitive. Many struggle for a balance. "It's an extremely
competitive place even at the preschool level," said Isabel Mah, 39, as
she waited for her 5-year-old son to finish Chinese class at the Chinese
cultural center. "I want my kid to be a kid but I want him to do well in
school." As Chinese influence grows, local political leaders are learning
that international disputes can now erupt at home. That's what happened in
June when Mayor Krom went to China to establish a sister city arrangement
with Xuhui, a region of Shanghai. She said a city staffer signed the
agreement before she saw it. The deal required Irvine to recognize the One
China Policy meaning China and Taiwan were one, not two, countries. It
also demanded that Irvine officials not travel to Taiwan where they have a
sister-city relationship with Taoyuan.
Shortly after, nearly 200 protesters, originally from Taiwan, showed up at
a City Council meeting, angry at what they saw as Irvine's kowtowing to
China. The council quickly rescinded the sister-city deal and said it
would renegotiate another only if it was strictly nonpolitical.
"Regardless of what was signed, we don't take our marching orders from
other countries," Krom said. Taiwanese and mainland Chinese residents of
Irvine insist there is no tension between them. "We treat the Taiwan-China
debate like religion you don't talk about it," said Rose Cheung. Her
friend Susie Chu said, "It's a fact, there are differences between the
Chu and Cheung belong to the Irvine Evergreen Chinese Senior Assn., a
group of about 400 senior citizens engaged in a wide array of cultural
activities. "My mom is 86 and never thought she could live in a place like
Irvine and not have to speak English," Chu said. Despite their growing
numbers, the Chinese Americans worry how they are perceived by the
community. "I think we have set a good example," said Yvonne Wang, 70,
president of the Evergreen association. "We have been very constructive to
society here." Cheung nodded.
"We still have our individuality," she said. "But collectively we are very
conscious about how we present ourselves." Across town, along a busy
street of low-slung warehouses, the sloping red roof of the Pao Fa Temple
rises. Guarded by stone dragons at the door, it is calm and quiet inside.
Incense burns. Buddhist nuns with shaved heads and brown robes chant
sutras in the Great Hall, where 3,000 golden Buddhas stare down on them.
The $5-million temple, one of the biggest in the nation, opened in 2002.
Irvine was selected, according to a nun, because the abbot received a sign
during meditation to put it here. After a recent service, a collection of
worshipers men on one side, women on the other silently ate in the spartan
When she finished, Ying Chow, 62, stepped into the library. She revels in
time spent at the temple, remembering when she had to drive to Hacienda
Heights to attend services. "Most of my friends are in Irvine now. It has
become a real community for the Chinese. But it's still surprising to see
this temple here," she said, folding her hands and smiling. "Orange County
has really changed. I feel good about it, I feel very special."
david.kelly at latimes.com Begin text of infobox
A multitude of Asian groups
Asian Americans account for almost 37% of Irvine's population, and people
of Chinese ancestry account for more than a third of the city's Asian
Americans. Irvine estimates the city's total population at 185,000, while
the 2005 census data estimate is 172,182.
In Irvine, the percentage of the population that is Asian American is
in Orange County 16%, and in the state 12.4%
Ethnic breakdown of Asian Americans, by region
Irvine Irvine Orange County Orange County California California
Number Percent of Number Percent of Number Percent of
in city city's Asians in O.C. O.C.'s Asians in state state's Asians
Asian Indian 9,008 14.3% 38,156 8.1% 449,722 10.3%
Chinese 21,757 34.5 74,802 15.8 1,113,844 25.5
Filipino 5,078 8.0 66,465 14.0 1,085,868 24.9
Japanese 3,694 5.8 28,571 6.0 311,559 7.1
Korean 11,422 18 74,999 15.9 401,980 9.2
Vietnamese 5,879 9.3 157,012 33.2 539,150 12.4
Other Asian 6,273 9.9 32,622 6.9 463,425 10.6
NOTE: Figures shown are from one race, not Asian combined with one or more
other races. Figures do not total 100% because of rounding.
Sources: U.S. census data; 2005 American Community Survey
Chinese in Irvine
Irvine's residents of Chinese ancestry make up a higher proportion of the
city's Asian population than in either the county or the state.
Chinese as a percentage of all Asians, by region
Of California's Asians - 25.5%
Of Orange County's Asians - 15.8%
Of Irvine's Asians - 34.5%
Sources: U.S. census data; 2005 American Community Survey
N.b.: Listing on the lgpolicy-list is merely intended as a service to its members
and implies neither approval, confirmation nor agreement by the owner or sponsor of
the list as to the veracity of a message's contents. Members who disagree with a
message are encouraged to post a rebuttal.
More information about the Lgpolicy-list