Oklahoma: American Indians Say English Only Policy Diminishes Tribal Languages

Harold F. Schiffman haroldfs at ccat.sas.upenn.edu
Mon Mar 12 13:46:28 UTC 2007

American Indians Say English Only Policy Diminishes Tribal Languages

AP - 3/11/2007 12:55 PM - Updated 3/12/2007 5:42 AM

OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) _ As he visits public schools and colleges where his
native Choctaw Indian language is taught, Terry Ragan is as likely to
greet people with ``Halito! Chim achukma?'' as he is with its English
equivalent: ``Good morning! How are you?'' The state's very name is a
Choctaw word meaning land of the red people, and many of Oklahoma's 37
federally recognized tribes are fighting to save native tongues from
extinction years after the end of organized efforts to stamp out their
languages and cultures. That's why English-only legislation pending in the
Oklahoma Legislature and directed primarily at Hispanic immigrants has
been so distasteful to American Indian leaders in this, Oklahoma's
centennial year.

The bill points up divisions that continue to exist more than a century
after Indians were force-marched to the state and given land, only to see
it taken away by settlers _ an event re-enacted every year by
schoolchildren across the state. ``If you go to English only, what are we
going to call the state of Oklahoma?'' said Ragan, a former school
superintendent and director of the Choctaw Nation's language program.
``Even town names in the state will have to be named differently. ``With
that type of thinking, we're going to have to change a whole lot of
things.'' Supporters of English-only legislation say it could eventually
end bilingual state government documents, such as driver's license tests,
and force Latino and Asian immigrants to learn English and assimilate into
American society.

English-only legislation has been adopted in 28 states and measures are
pending in 12 states, said Rob Toonkel, director of communications for
U.S. English, Inc. of Washington, D.C. A similar measure has been filed in
Congress. The national English only movement does not want to deprive
American Indians of their native languages but is aimed at standardizing
government documents into a single language as a symbol of unity for
immigrant populations. ``It's very much an assimilation issue,'' Toonkel
said. ``We should make sure they become part of the country.'' But
assimilation is a charged word for many American Indians, whose ancestors
were forced from their traditional lands and sent on the Trail of Tears in
the 19th century.

English-only restrictions were imposed in what was then known as Indian
Territory to expunge tribal languages and culture, said Kirke Kickingbird,
an Oklahoma City attorney and member of the Kiowa tribe. ``That whole era
was really about assimilation,'' he said. Indian men were forced to cut
their hair and change their clothes and Indian children were herded off to
boarding schools away from the influence of their parents. Even the
unassigned lands set aside for Indian tribes were eventually carved up for
settlement in land runs beginning in 1889, events that led to Oklahoma's
statehood in 1907. Every year, school children throughout the state dress
up as pioneers and stage pretend land runs to learn about the state's

Organizers of a year-long centennial celebration said it would unite
Oklahomans, but some tribal leaders said they feel alienated. ``We're just
not going to celebrate it in our nation,'' said A.D. Ellis, principal
chief of the 55,000-thousand-member Muscogee Nation. ``I think they should
respect the Indian people of Oklahoma,'' Ellis said.  ``They should
respect that part we played in making the state of Oklahoma.  This is a
native American state.''

Chad Smith, chief of the 250,000-thousand member Cherokee Nation, the
largest American Indian tribe in the United States, said the state's image
is harmed when cultural differences are not embraced. ``There's a message
sent to those outside of Oklahoma that we're intolerant, we're colloquial
and we want to isolate ourselves from the rest of the world,'' Smith said.
``To our tribes it says that if there's an official language, your
language is secondary and all other languages are secondary,'' said Smith,
who has also been an outspoken critic of use of Indian mascots and names
by athletic teams. Bill Anoatubby, governor of the 38,000-member Chickasaw
Nation, said language is a fundamental aspect of any culture. ``Oklahoma
is a unique state born from and formed by a variety of cultures,''
Anoatubby said. ``The English only bill ignores the very fabric that makes
up the framework of what is Oklahoma.''

Wyman Kirk, a member of the Cherokee tribe and director of a four-year
degree program in the Cherokee language at Northeastern State University
in Tahlequah, Okla., said he believes the English only proposal is a waste
of politicians' time. ``We don't have to worry about people not learning
English,'' Kirk said. Supporters point out that the legislation includes
language to prevent it from interfering with the teaching or learning of
American Indian languages. But critics said a government policy on
language could impede efforts to revive tribal languages. The Intertribal
Wordpath Society, a nonprofit group based in Norman, Okla., estimates that
only about 9,000 people are fluent in the Cherokee language and 4,000 in
the Choctaw language.

Fewer than a dozen people are fluent in other American Indian languages,
including those of the Osage, Pawnee and Chiricahua Apache tribes,
according to the group. Kirk said that lack of understanding, or
``uhnigvga'' in Cherokee, may be at the heart of the policy. ``Anything
new tends to scare people,'' Kirk said. ``If anything, I think people
probably need to be exposed to more languages.'' Alice Anderton, a former
linguist at the University of Oklahoma and executive director of the
Intertribal Wordpath Society, said a xenophobic fear that immigrants will
somehow change society may be to blame for the policy. ``We feel it's fine
for everyone to speak English, but its also important for people to speak
other languages,'' Anderton said. She said English only policies are
divisive and exclude people from other cultures.

``This whole idea of English uniting us is bogus,'' Anderton said. ``The
truth is people are divided by a thousand things _ different politics,
different religions.'' ``We have absolutely nothing against English. It's
great if people speak English,'' she said. ``But it's great if people
speak English plus some other language of heritage.



N.b.: Listing on the lgpolicy-list is merely intended as a service to its members
and implies neither approval, confirmation nor agreement by the owner or sponsor of
the list as to the veracity of a message's contents. Members who disagree with a
message are encouraged to post a rebuttal.


More information about the Lgpolicy-list mailing list