Turkish Schools Offer Pakistan a Gentler Islam (and in English medium, too)

Harold Schiffman hfsclpp at gmail.com
Sun May 4 17:06:38 UTC 2008

May 4, 2008
 Turkish Schools Offer Pakistan a Gentler Islam By SABRINA

KARACHI, Pakistan<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/international/countriesandterritories/pakistan/index.html?inline=nyt-geo>—
Praying in Pakistan has not been easy for Mesut Kacmaz, a Muslim
from Turkey.

He tried the mosque near his house, but it had Israeli and Danish flags
painted on the floor for people to step on. The mosque near where he works
warned him never to return wearing a tie. Pakistanis everywhere assume he is
not Muslim because he has no beard. "Kill, fight, shoot," Mr. Kacmaz said.
"This is a misinterpretation of Islam." But that view is common in Pakistan,
a frontier land for the future of Islam, where schools, nourished by Saudi
and American money dating back to the 1980s, have spread Islamic radicalism
through the poorest parts of society. With a literacy rate of just 50
percent and a public school system near collapse, the country is
particularly vulnerable.

Mr. Kacmaz (pronounced KATCH-maz) is part of a group of Turkish educators
who have come to this battleground with an entirely different vision of
Islam. Theirs is moderate and flexible, comfortably coexisting with the West
while remaining distinct from it. Like Muslim Peace
they promote this approach in schools, which are now established
in more than 80 countries, Muslim and Christian. Their efforts are important
in Pakistan, a nuclear power whose stability and whose vulnerability to
fundamentalism have become main preoccupations of American foreign policy.
Its tribal areas have become a refuge to the
and the battle against fundamentalism rests squarely on young people and the
education they get.

At present, that education is extremely weak. The poorest Pakistanis cannot
afford to send their children to public schools, which are free but require
fees for books and uniforms. Some choose to send their children to madrasas,
or religious schools, which, like aid organizations, offer free food and
clothing. Many simply teach, but some have radical agendas. At the same
time, a growing middle class is rejecting public schools, which are chaotic
and poorly financed, and choosing from a new array of private schools. The
Turkish schools, which have expanded to seven cities in Pakistan since the
first one opened a decade ago, cannot transform the country on their own.
But they offer an alternative approach that could help reduce the influence
of Islamic extremists.

They prescribe a strong Western curriculum, with courses, taught in English,
from math and science to English literature and Shakespeare. They do not
teach religion beyond the one class in Islamic studies that is required by
the state. Unlike British-style private schools, however, they encourage
Islam in their dormitories, where teachers set examples in lifestyle and
prayer. "Whatever the West has of science, let our kids have it," said Erkam
Aytav, a Turk who works in the new schools. "But let our kids have their
religion as well."

That approach appeals to parents in Pakistan, who want their children to be
capable of competing with the West without losing their identities to it.
Allahdad Niazi, a retired Urdu professor in Quetta, a frontier town near the
Afghan border, took his son out of an elite military school, because it was
too authoritarian and did not sufficiently encourage Islam, and put him in
the Turkish school, called PakTurk.

"Private schools can't make our sons good Muslims," Mr. Niazi said, sitting
on the floor in a Quetta house. "Religious schools can't give them modern
education. PakTurk does both."

The model is the brainchild of a Turkish Islamic scholar, Fethullah Gulen. A
preacher with millions of followers in Turkey, Mr. Gulen, 69, comes from a
tradition of Sufism, an introspective, mystical strain of Islam. He has
lived in exile in the United States since 2000, after getting in trouble
with secular Turkish officials. Mr. Gulen's idea, Mr. Aytav said, is that
"without science, religion turns to radicalism, and without religion,
science is blind and brings the world to danger."

The schools are putting into practice a Turkish Sufi philosophy that took
its most modern form during the last century, after Mustafa Kemal
Turkey's founder, crushed the Islamic caliphate in the 1920s. Islamic
thinkers responded by trying to bring Western science into the faith they
were trying to defend. In the 1950s, while Arab Islamic intellectuals like
Sayyid Qutub were firmly rejecting the West, Turkish ones like Said Nursi
were seeking ways to coexist with it.

In Karachi, a sprawling city that has had its own struggles with radicalism
— the American reporter Daniel
killed here, and the famed Binori madrasa here is said to have
Osama bin Laden<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/b/osama_bin_laden/index.html?inline=nyt-per>—
the two approaches compete daily. The Turkish school is in a poor
neighborhood in the south of the city where residents are mostly Pashtun, a
strongly tribal ethnic group whose poorer fringes have been among the most
susceptible to radicalism. Mr. Kacmaz, who became principal 10 months ago,
ran into trouble almost as soon as he began. The locals were suspicious of
the Turks, who, with their ties and clean-shaven faces, looked like math
teachers from Middle America.

"They asked me several times, 'Are they Muslim? Do they pray? Are they
drinking at night?' " said Ali Showkat, a vice principal of the school, who
is Pakistani. Goats nap by piles of rubbish near the school's entrance, and
Mr. Kacmaz asked a local religious leader to help get people to stop
throwing their trash near the school, to no avail. Exasperated, he hung an
Islamic saying on the outer wall of the school: "Cleanliness is half of
faith." When he prayed at a mosque, two young men followed him out and told
him not to return wearing a tie because it was un-Islamic. "I said, 'Show me
a verse in the Koran where it was forbidden,' " Mr. Kacmaz said, steering
his car through tangled rush-hour traffic. The two men were wearing glasses,
and he told them that scripturally, there was no difference between a tie
and glasses.

"Behind their words there was no Hadith," he said, referring to a set of
Islamic texts, "only misunderstanding." That misunderstanding, along with
the radicalism that follows, stalks the poorest parts of Quetta. Abdul Bari,
a 31-year-old teacher of Islam from a religious family, lives in a
neighborhood without electricity or running water. Two brothers from his
tribe were killed on a suicide mission, leaving their mother a beggar and
angering Mr. Bari, who says a Muslim's first duty is to his mother and his
family. "Our nation has no patience," said Mr. Bari, who raised his seven
younger siblings, after his father died suddenly a dozen years ago. He
decided that one of his brothers should be educated, and enrolled him in the
Turkish school.

The Turks put the focus on academics, which pleased Mr. Bari, who said his
dream was for Saadudeen, his brother, to lift the family out of poverty and
expand its horizons beyond religion. Mr. Bari's title, hafiz, means he has
memorized the entire Koran, though he has no formal education. Two other
brothers have earned the same distinction. Their father was an imam. His is
a lonely mission in a neighborhood where nearly all the residents are
illiterate and most disapprove of his choices, Mr. Bari said. He is
constantly on guard against extremism. He once punished Saadudeen for flying
kites with the wrong kind of boys. At the Turkish school, the teenager is
supervised around the clock in a dormitory.

"They are totally against extremism," Mr. Bari said of the Turks. "They are
true Muslims. They will make my brother into a true Muslim. He'll deal with
people with justice and wisdom. Not with impatience." Illiteracy is one of
the roots of problems dogging the Muslim world, said Matiullah Aail, a
religious scholar in Quetta who graduated from Medina University in Saudi
Arabia. In Baluchistan, Quetta's sparsely populated province, the literacy
rate is less than 10 percent, said Tariq Baluch, a government official in
the Pasheen district. He estimated that about half of the district's
children attended madrasas.

Mr. Aail said: "Doctors and lawyers have to show their degrees. But when it
comes to mullahs, no one asks them for their qualifications. They don't have
knowledge, but they are influential." That leads to a skewed interpretation
of Islam, even by those schooled in it, according to Mr. Gulen and his
followers.  "They've memorized the entire holy book, but they don't
understand its meaning," said Kamil Ture, a Turkish administrator. Mr.
Kacmaz chimed in: "How we interpret the Koran is totally dependent on our

In an interview in 2004, published in a book of his writings, Mr. Gulen put
it like this: "In the countries where Muslims live, some religious leaders
and immature Muslims have no other weapon in hand than their fundamental
interpretation of Islam. They use this to engage people in struggles that
serve their own purposes." Moderate as that sounds, some Turks say Mr. Gulen
uses the schools to advance his own political agenda. Murat Belge, a
prominent Turkish intellectual who has experience with the movement, said
that Mr. Gulen "sincerely believes that he has been chosen by God," and
described Mr. Gulen's followers as "Muslim Jesuits" who are preparing elites
to run the country.

Hakan Yavuz, a Turkish professor at the University of
has had extensive experience with the Gulen movement, offered a darker
assessment. "The purpose here is very much power," Mr. Yavuz said. "The
model of power is the Ottoman Empire and the idea that Turks should shape
the Muslim world." But while radical Islamists seek to re-establish a
seventh-century Islamic caliphate, without nations or borders, and more
moderate Islamists, like Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, use secular democracy
to achieve the goal of an Islamic state, Mr. Gulen is a nationalist who says
he wants no more than a secular democracy where citizens are free to
worship, a claim secular Turks find highly suspect.

Still, his schools are richly supported by Turkish businessmen. M. Ihsan
Kalkavan, a shipping magnate who has built hotels in Nigeria, helped finance
Gulen schools there, which he said had attracted the children of the
Nigerian elite. "When we take our education experiment to other countries,
we introduce ourselves. We say, 'See, we're not terrorists.' When people get
to know us, things change," Mr. Kalkavan said in his office in Istanbul.

He estimated the number of Mr. Gulen's followers in Turkey at three million
to five million. The network itself does not provide estimates, and Mr.
Gulen declined to be interviewed. The schools, which also operate in
Christian countries like Russia, are not for Muslims alone, and one of their
stated aims is to promote interfaith understanding. Mr. Gulen met the
previous pope, as well as Jewish and Orthodox Christian leaders, and
teachers in the schools say they stress multiculturalism and universal
values. "We are all humans," said Mr. Kacmaz, the principal. "In Islam,
every human being is very important."

Pakistani society is changing fast, and more Pakistanis are realizing the
importance of education, in part because they have more to lose, parents
said. Abrar Awan, whose son is attending the Turkish school in Quetta, said
he had grown tired of the attitude of the Islamic political parties he
belonged to as a student. Now a government employee with a steady job, he
sees real life as more complicated than black-and-white ideology. "America
or the West was always behind every fault, every problem," he said, at a
gathering of fathers in April. "Now, in my practical life, I know the faults
are within us."

Sebnem Arsu contributed reporting from Karachi and Quetta in Pakistan and
from Istanbul.

N.b.: Listing on the lgpolicy-list is merely intended as a service to its
and implies neither approval, confirmation nor agreement by the owner or
sponsor of
the list as to the veracity of a message's contents. Members who disagree
with a
message are encouraged to post a rebuttal. (H. Schiffman, Moderator)
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listserv.linguistlist.org/pipermail/lgpolicy-list/attachments/20080504/7923dd65/attachment.html>

More information about the Lgpolicy-list mailing list