State Farm Blasts LPGA English Proficiency Policy; Insurer Tells Golf Group It May 'Re-Examine' Sponsorship
hfsclpp at gmail.com
Wed Sep 3 14:58:54 UTC 2008
State Farm Blasts LPGA English Proficiency Policy
Insurer Tells Golf Group It May 'Re-Examine' Sponsorship
By Michael Bush
Published: September 02, 2008
NEW YORK (AdAge.com) -- Saying it was "flabbergasted" by the Ladies
Professional Golf Association's new policy requiring "effective
communication in English on the part of all of our Tour members,"
State Farm is urging the group to reconsider -- or the insurer may
reconsider its sponsorship. State Farm is both a general sponsor of
the LPGA as well as the sponsor of the State Farm Classic Tournament.
"It's something we are dumfounded by," said Kip Biggs, media-relations
specialist at the insurer, which is a general sponsor of the league as
well as of the State Farm Classic Tournament in Springfield, Ill. "We
don't understand this and don't know why they have done it, and we
have strongly encouraged them to take another look at this."
LPGA defends position
The LPGA claims that the language barrier facing a number of its
players is causing problems on many fronts, including the players'
dealings with the media as well as the league's sponsors and the
customers of those sponsors. Mr. Biggs, however, said State Farm was
unaware that the LPGA was contemplating any such policy. While he
would not disclose the value of State Farm's LPGA sponsorship, which
runs through next year, he said the policy was something that the
company would take into consideration when deciding whether to
continue its relationship with the league when its contract expires.
"We're looking at all of our options, but we would hope it would not
come to [ending the partnership]," he said. "But this policy does
concern us greatly, and as you could imagine, when [the sponsorship]
comes up for review, it's something we'll take into account when we
look at either re-upping or walking away. We made that commitment, and
we're going to honor it, but we reserve the right to re-examine our
sponsorships. Right now we have just let them know that this is
something we are not pleased with."
State Farm isn't the only sponsor taking note. David Peikin, senior
director-corporate communications at Choice Hotels International,
said, "We have a great deal of interest in the intentions of the LPGA
on this subject. Based on our understanding, this policy is currently
under review by the LPGA, and a final decision and any related details
will be determined over the next four months. Until that time, we will
be closely monitoring LPGA news and announcements."
While the LPGA has issued a statement defending its policy, the group
did not return calls at press time regarding the comments of State
Farm or other sponsors.
Ann Wool, senior VP-director at Ketchum Sports network, said it was a
mistake for the LPGA not to talk to its sponsors before announcing the
policy. "When making a major policy decision it's always wise to
notify your sponsors," Ms. Wool said. "I can only speculate that [the
LPGA] didn't think this was going to be such a controversial issue,
otherwise they probably would have. It was probably a bad move not to
notify their sponsors."
Ms. Wool said she understands the intent of the league but that its
execution was wrong. "The fact that they are calling it a policy is a
problem," she said. "From a PR standpoint that's the fundamental
problem. Offering and encouraging players to improve their English so
they help themselves and the league be more media-friendly is great.
But when you make it a policy and threaten people it turns the whole
thing on its head."
Since its announcement, the league has been catching heat from a
number of sources including sports writers, community groups and
AdAge.com readers. The statement that the league issued today hoped to
clarify the group's position on the matter by saying it has worked for
many years to improve the language skills of its players through
tutors and translators. Instead, the statement seemed to add credence
to the argument that the policy is self-serving and only being issued
because the league is afraid of losing sponsorship dollars.
"It is imperative for the future success of the LPGA as well as the
success of each LPGA player that our members effectively communicate
in English at tournaments inside the United States with those who
provide for the existence of the tournaments and the opportunities for
professional women golfers to make a living doing what they love," the
statement reads. "Much of the criticism of our policy has centered
around the LPGA's penalty for players who do not meet the minimum
language threshold. The penalty is meant to underscore the importance
of this issue to the LPGA's long-term business success."
LPGA may need better communication skills
Mr. Biggs doesn't believe the statement is going to accomplish what
the league is hoping it will. "There are ways to communicate things
and it really sounds like the commissioner [Carolyn F. Bivens] did not
listen to what the communications people around her might have
encouraged her to [say] or to communicate this in a different way," he
"You can see what's intended," Mr. Biggs said, adding, "There's no way
I would allow one of my executives to make a statement like this or
implement this policy. The policy is troubling. It's one thing to want
to be able to promote your product and have players communicate to
your sponsors. But when you start to require that people do something
and then back it up with penalties, that goes a mighty long way and
According to the LPGA's site, there are 478 LPGA tour members. The
Associated Press reported that there are 121 international players
from 26 countries on the tour, including 45 players from South Korea.
N.b.: Listing on the lgpolicy-list is merely intended as a service to
and implies neither approval, confirmation nor agreement by the owner
or sponsor of
the list as to the veracity of a message's contents. Members who
disagree with a
message are encouraged to post a rebuttal. (H. Schiffman, Moderator)
More information about the Lgpolicy-list