[lg policy] BBC Translation challenges: From gang slang to poetic rabbits
wfierman at indiana.edu
Fri Aug 21 11:07:44 UTC 2015
Translation challenges: From gang slang to poetic rabbits
By Donna Bowater Paraty, Brazil
21 August 2015
From the section Latin America & Caribbean
Paulo Coelho's novel The Alchemist has been translated into 67 languages
Brazilian author Paulo Coelho's novel The Alchemist has spent almost seven years on the New York Times bestseller list.
The novel about a Spanish shepherd's voyage to Egypt gained immediate popularity in the author's native Brazil.
But Coelho himself has credited the translation into English in 1994 for his novel's international success.
"In the publishing world outside of the United States, nobody reads Spanish, much less Portuguese," he told the New York Times in a 1999 interview.
"Translation into English made it possible for other editors to read me."
Now The Alchemist is available in 67 languages.
But translating Brazilian Portuguese for an English-speaking audience is no easy task.
>From words that have no equivalent to cultural references and concepts, translators must find a balance between being faithful to the original work while giving the reader the most accurate understanding of Brazilianisms.
"It's important not to treat the reader like an idiot," says Zoe Perry, translator of Coelho's latest novel, Adultery.
"I only put in footnotes things that are very culturally specific, that only those who grew up in Brazil would know.
"If it's something you can easily put into Google and find, it's better to leave it."
References to Brazil's military dictatorship from 1964 to 1985 and its sizeable population of Japanese immigrants are among those sometimes left unexplained.
Yet although today's readers can easily cross-reference queries online within seconds, Brazilian literature sometimes deals with issues so specific that even native readers may not recognise them.
Paulo Lins's novel City of God, which was turned into a box office hit movie of the same name in 2002, was about drug gang culture within Rio's favelas, a concept that is itself often misunderstood.
The novel is full of street slang, including the creative gang nicknames such as Seu Jorge's character Mane Galinha (Mane being short for Manuel and Galinha literally meaning "chicken", as well as being used as a term for someone who has many partners).
Alison Entrekin, who translated City of God into English, in the end settled on Knockout.
"Sometimes, the translator has to choose something when it is simply impossible to find an equivalent word," she explains.
Alison Entrekin was speaking at the International Literary Festival in Paraty
Ms Entrekin says that sometimes it is not just foreign readers who will be unacquainted with certain terms but native speakers, too, especially if the words used are particular to a certain group.
"If the book is cultured, it's easier but with lower registers, it's more of a problem, and it was like this translating City of God," she says.
Other things are specific to a certain region.
She says she once translated a book that made reference to an "azulejado", an outdoor barbecue area decorated with blue tiling.
"It's an immediate image that Brazilians would know," she said but one which can test translators.
Ms Entrekin said one of her most recent translation challenges was a children's book about a poet bunny rabbit called Fuzz McFlops.
The book is partly about the rabbit's frustrated attempts at poetry and partly about different forms of communication, including letters, addresses and the Brazilian equivalent of a postcode.
"Despite being for children, it was very complicated." Ms Entrekin recalls.
"It was full of puns. I had to reinvent everything," she says.
"If there's a joke that works in one language but not in another, you have to tell another joke."
In the end, the part of the book dealing with the different forms of communication took her five times longer to translate than another book of the same size.
Share of the credit
Ms Perry says working together with other translators sometimes helps, especially when the authors are not available to help with queries or questions.
Zoe Perry says it is important translators get recognition for their work
"I didn't have contact with the author of the first book I translated and I felt the absence," she says.
"And with Paulo Coelho's book, I also had no contact with him. I imagine he has a lot of translators."
But, as Coelho's career has shown, translators are essential to promoting Brazilian literature around the world and, depending on their individual agreements, they receive a percentage of the royalties from book sales as well as a fixed fee for the translation.
"In the case of Paulo Coelho, I insist on royalties," jokes Ms Perry.
"But there are others for which I'll never receive royalties," she says.
Royalties or not, what is important to her is that the editor values the translator's work: "The fact that you contribute to the success of the book."
Share this story About sharing
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
-------------- next part --------------
This message came to you by way of the lgpolicy-list mailing list
lgpolicy-list at groups.sas.upenn.edu
To manage your subscription unsubscribe, or arrange digest format: https://groups.sas.upenn.edu/mailman/listinfo/lgpolicy-list
More information about the Lgpolicy-list