17.1024, Sum: Word Order in Russian and Other Related Issues
linguist at LINGUISTLIST.ORG
linguist at LINGUISTLIST.ORG
Wed Apr 5 14:40:07 UTC 2006
LINGUIST List: Vol-17-1024. Wed Apr 05 2006. ISSN: 1068 - 4875.
Subject: 17.1024, Sum: Word Order in Russian and Other Related Issues
Moderators: Anthony Aristar, Wayne State U <aristar at linguistlist.org>
Helen Aristar-Dry, Eastern Michigan U <hdry at linguistlist.org>
Reviews (reviews at linguistlist.org)
Sheila Dooley, U of Arizona
Terry Langendoen, U of Arizona
Homepage: http://linguistlist.org/
The LINGUIST List is funded by Eastern Michigan University, Wayne
State University, and donations from subscribers and publishers.
Editor for this issue: James Rider <rider at linguistlist.org>
================================================================
To post to LINGUIST, use our convenient web form at
http://linguistlist.org/LL/posttolinguist.html.
===========================Directory==============================
1)
Date: 03-Apr-2006
From: Bingfu Lu < lubingfy at yahoo.com >
Subject: Word Order in Russian and Other Related Issues
-------------------------Message 1 ----------------------------------
Date: Wed, 05 Apr 2006 10:37:49
From: Bingfu Lu < lubingfy at yahoo.com >
Subject: Word Order in Russian and Other Related Issues
Editor's note: This issue contains non-ISO-8859-1 characters.
To view the correct characters, go to http://linguistlist.org/issues/17/17-1024.html.
Regarding query: http://linguistlist.org/issues/17/17-925.html#1
One week ago, in a posting, I raised two question. One requests for
counterexamples to an assumed word order universal (the OV order implies TV
[time adverbial + V] order). The other asks whether the Russian uses TV or
VT as the canonical order.
I got 9 responses so far. No one provided counterexample to the assumed
universal. About the Russian word order, the stories are very different
among the responses.
3 For TV (Harold Schefski, Linda Apse, Dmitry Gerasimov)
3 for VT; (Evgenia Sokolinskaia, Marian Sloboda, Olga Zavitnevich-Beaulac)
2 not clear (Ora Matushansky,
1 the answer is irrelevant (Ora Matushansky: [by 'time adverbials', I mean
the definite time location, not frequency])
I guess the assumed word order universal is related to that the time
adverbial has a strong tendency to appear initially cross-linguistically.
Years ago, I did a rough investigation on the word order among adverbial:
(Time, Duration, Location (of place), Instrument, Manner). The following
was the result.
1: T D L I M V
(Japanese, Korean, Basque)
2: T L I M V D
Chinese
3: T D M V I L
Tagalot
4: T D V M I L
Hebrew
5: T V M I L D
Russian
6: V M I L D T
English, Vietnamese, Portuguese, Yoruba, Thai
I generalized the variants into a unique 'orbital structure' as follows:
{{{{{{V}M}I}L}D}T}, where the {} represents the distance to the head verb,
linear order being irrelevant here. From these variants, it seems the time
adverbial tends to precede most. This may be relevant to the assumed I
mentioned here (OV implies VT). In fact, in English, T is frequently
fronted. It seems the easiest to be fronted among these adverbials.
According to the responses to my previous posting, Russian should be
replaced by Latvian. Now, I would like to solicit for the orders of these
adverbials in other languages. I will make a summary if the responses are
significant in number.
Bingfu Lu
Institute of Linguistics,
Shanghai Normal University
Appendix: (all responses to my previous posting)
1.
Harold Schefski (California State University, Long Beach)
In Russian there is a rule about word order which says that the new
information comes last in the sentence. This means that variant number one
is the response to Kogda Vy ego videli? Ya videl ego vchera. Numbers two
and three are both possible for the question Kogo Vy vchera videli? Again
the new information coming last in the response to the interrogative. I
cannot say whether two or three is a better variant in this situation only
that they are both possible and sound fine. However, number four is totally
unnatural to Russian because time should precede the verb unless it is the
newest information in the sentence as in number one.
1. ? ?????? ??? ?????.
2. ? ????? ?????? ???.
3. ????? ? ?????? ???.
4. *? ?????? ????? ??? .
2.
Evgenia Sokolinskaia (Hamburg University)
I am a linguist of English but a Russian native speaker and I would also
think that the basic order in Russian, which is a SVO language, would be
Vt, at least time adverbial phrases will nearly always be placed after the
verb. The difficulty is presented by one-word adverbials and the relative
freedom of Russian word order which is in most cases conditioned by the
windowing of attention in a sentence (cp. Ya vídel ego vcherá = I saw him
YESTERDAY vs. Ya ego vcherá vídel = I SAW him yesterday).
English is surely SVO + Vt language.
3.
Ora Matushansky
(1) Both orders are possible:
Masha chasto boleet
M often is.sick
-- default
Masha boleet chasto
-- focus on frequently
(2) In the exx. above, this has to do with the fact that the sentence-final
element is focussed.
Masha chasto govorit po telefonu
M frequently speaks on phone
-- default
Masha govorit chasto po telefonu
M speaks frequently on phone
-- marked, and I don't really know in what way (information structure)
If you front the object or do something else that makes the verb final
here, this is VERY marked (also from the pov of information structure),
and so the adverb ends up after the verb to make the word-order less marked
(I'm sorry I'm not speaking in the generative terms, but it's not like I
have an analysis, and the pure description might be easier). In this
case, putting the adverb after the verb is the default option:
Po telefonu Masha govorit chasto
As for using the phone, Masha does so frequently
Also, if the object becomes preverbal because it is a pronoun (there's
something like object shift in Russian then) or a quantifier like all
(a short one), the same effect comes into play - the adverb becomes final.
4.
Ora Matushansky
My intuition is that if you have an adverbial that is longer than one word,
then all depends on how heavy other post-verbal elements are. It sort of
makes sense because the longer an element is, the more likely it is to be
new information/focalized. I believe you can find the same kind of effects
in Romance DP vis-a-vis the order of NP-complement, (right-branching)
adjectives and PPs:
Masha boleet chashche chem Petja
M is.sick more.often than P
Masha chashche chem Petja boleet
-- v marked, verum focus + contrastive topics on M and P, I think
Masha boleet korju chashche chem Petja
M is.sick with.mumps more.often than P
-- default (even though you can't be sick with mumps more than once, I
don't think)
Masha chashche chem Petja boleet korju
-- focus on mumps
5.
Marian Sloboda
I do not have any statistics for you, but I think that the basic order
in Russian is VO, but Vt, although Russian, being a language with
relatively free word order, can have tV (as well as OV - for emphasis)
order. The position of t might also depend on the fact if there is an
object in the sentence or not, but I am not sure how that looks like
in quantitative terms.
6.
Linda Apse
I am a native speaker of Latvian ( a balto-slavic language) and I speak
Russian too. In Latvian, which is a VO lanaguage, the canonical is tV
order, like in Es rit atnaksu ( I will tomorrow come) (future is
morphologically marked on the verb) A Vt order is a marked order.
As far as I am aware, the same is true of Russian.
7.
Olga Kagan
I'd say that in Russian the standard order is Vt. Some examples are the
following:
Dima prishol domoj v polovine sed'mogo.
Dima came home in half seventh
Dima came home at half past six.
Ja xozhu v klub po vtornikam.
I go to club on Tuesdays.
Lena byla u Petji na proshloj nedele.
Lena was at Petja on last week
Lena visited Petja last week.
Since Russian is a language with a rather free word order, other orders are
possible. However, the standard order seems to be as exemplified in the
sentences above.
8.
Dmitry Gerasimov
I'd rather say both as a native speaker and as a linguist interested in
Russian aspectual composition, that your impression is right. Russian uses
both tV and Vt orders, and though I cannot provide you with any statistics,
tV order is apparently more frequent. Vt order is mostly used when the
temporal adverbial is focused. I can provide you with many examples if you
are interested.
9.
Olga Zavitnevich-Beaulac
Russian is a discourse configurational language, which means the word
order is relatively free and as you rightly notice both tV and Vt orders are
attested in the language depending what information is more relevant in
discourse: topicalized and focused constituents tend to appear clause
initially at the left periphery. However, the basic neutral order is VO
and Vt.
Linguistic Field(s): Typology
Subject Language(s): Russian (rus)
-----------------------------------------------------------
This Year the LINGUIST List hopes to raise $52,932. This money will go to help keep the
List running by supporting all of our Student Editors for the coming year.
See below for donation instructions, and don't forget to check out our Fund Drive 2006
LINGUIST List Cruise for some Fund Drive fun!
http://linguistlist.org/cruise.html
There are many ways to donate to LINGUIST!
You can donate right now using our secure credit card form.
Alternatively you can also pledge right now and pay later.
For all information on donating and pledging, including information on how to donate by
check, money order, or wire transfer, please visit:
http://linguistlist.org/donate.html
The LINGUIST List is under the umbrella of Eastern Michigan University and as such can
receive donations through the EMU Foundation, which is a registered 501(c) Non Profit
organization. Our Federal Tax number is 38-6005986. These donations can be offset against
your federal and sometimes your state tax return (U.S. tax payers only). For more
information visit the IRS Web-Site, or contact your financial advisor.
Many companies also offer a gift matching program, such that they will match any gift
you make to a non-profit organization. Normally this entails your contacting your human
resources department and sending us a form that the EMU Foundation fills in and returns
to your employer. This is generally a simple administrative procedure that doubles the
value of your gift to LINGUIST, without costing you an extra penny. Please take a moment
to check if your company operates such a program.
Thank you very much for your support of LINGUIST!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We would like to thank all of the publishers and subscribers who
donated prizes for this year's Fund Drive games, puzzles and
competitions.
Publisher Prize Donors:
Blackwell
Cascadilla Press
Continuum
Estudios de Sociolingüística
John Benjamins
The Linguistic Association of Finland
Multilingual Matters
MultiLingual magazine
PORTA LINGUARUM
Speculative Grammarian
Springer
The Surrey Morphology Group
Institute of the Czech National Corpus
Subscriber Prize Donors:
Paul G. Chapin
Katherine Chen
Madalena Cruz-Ferreira
Dr. Gabriel Dorta
Suzette Haden Elgin
Gang Gu
Elly van Gelderen
Sara Laviosa
Carol Myers-Scotton
Loraine K. Obler, Ph.D
Ana María Ortega and María Luisa Pérez
Pernille Pennington
Claus Pusch
Michael Swan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The LINGUIST List Hall of Fame
ANGELS ($1000 and over)
Arnold Zwicky
MAINSTAYS ($100 to $1000)
A. Henderson, S. Moran, G. Stamm
Andrea Levitt
Andrew Carnie
Anita Fetzer
Antonella Sorace
Arienne M. Dwyer
Aygul Fitton-Brown
Baden Hughes
Barbara H Partee
Bernadine W. Raiskums
Bernard Spolsky
Billy Clark
CaroLyn Green Hartnett
Cecile McKee
Cinzia Russi
Columbia School Linguistic Society
Cynthia Edmiston
Cynthia Tia Linn Johnson
D Terence Langendoen
Danny Moates
Daria Suk
David Bowie
Douglas Dee
Dr. MJ Hardman
Edward Garrett
Elaine J. Francis and Alexander L. Francis
Ellen Woolford and John McCarthy
elly van gelderen
Emily M. Bender
Emmon W Bach
Ernest McCarus
Eugenia Casielles
Frances Trix
Geoff Nathan and Margaret Winters
Gerardo Lorenzino
Heike Behrens
Helen Aristar-Dry & Anthony Aristar
Hubert Cuyckens
Jason Boston and Marisa Ferrara
Jeff Good
Jeff Mielke
Jeff Siegel
John Lawler
John Nerbonne
Julie Auger
Justine Cassell
Karen Davis
Karen Milligan
Katy Carlson
Kemp Williams
Keren Rice
Kevin Gregg
Kirk Hazen
Kristy Beers Fägersten
Kübler Sandra
Laura Buszard-Welcher
Laura Callahan
Line Mikkelsen
Manuela Noske
Margaret Speas
Maribel Romero
Mark Overstreet
Michael Silverstein
Michael Swan
Monica Macaulay and Joe Salmons
Natasha Warner
Neil Olsen
Pacific Languages Unit, USP
Pam and Allen Munro
Pius ten Hacken
Prashant Nagaraja
Revue Romane
Rochelle Lieber
Sally McConnell-Ginet
Sandra Fotos
Sanford Steever
Shanley Allen
Shirley Silver
Simin Karimi
Stefan Th. Gries
Steven Gross
University of Pennsylvania Linguistics Club
Ute Römer
Wannie Carstens
Wayles Browne
Wendy Wilkins
Wynn Chao
Wynn Chao and Emmon Bach
Yoko Hasegawa
Zenzi Griffin
- Plus 5 anonymous donors
SUPPORTERS ($50 to $100)
Aaron Huey Sonnenschein
Adam and Andy Ussishkin and Wedel
Alexander Brock
Alice Turk & Bert Remijsen
Alicia Pousada
Alison Gabriele
Andrea C. Schalley
Andrew Linn
Anette Rosenbach
Anja Wanner
Ann Wehmeyer
Anna Fowles-Winkler
Anne Barron
Aoyama
Arsalan Kahnemuyipour
Barbora Skarabela and Mits Ota
Bruce Spencer
Carol A. Klee
Cassandre Creswell
Catherine Anderson
Christina Villafana Dalcher
Christine Gunlogson
Claude Mauk
Claus D. Pusch
Clyde Hankey
Cristina Piva
Cynthia Gordon
Deborah Anderson
Don Rubin
Eduardo Urios-Aparisi
Eric Haeberli
Eva Schultze-Berndt
Francesca Del Gobbo
Francisco Dubert
Frauke Zeller
Gail Stygall
Georgetown University - Graduate Student Linguistics Association
Grover Hudson
Heidi Harley
Henrik Jørgensen
Hernan Emilio Perez
Hortènsia Curell
Huei-ling Lai
Inge Genee
Ingrid Piller
Irina Temnikova
Ivano Caponigro
James Lavine
Jean Mulder
Jennifer Cole
Jennifer L Smith
Jie Zhang
Jila Ghomeshi
Joana Rossello
Joaquim Barbosa
Job M. van Zuijlen
Johanna Laakso
Jose-Luis Mendivil
Josep M. Fontana and Louise McNally
Josep Quer
Joybrato Mukherjee
Juan Carlos Rubio
Judith Meinschaefer
Judy Reilly
kar lok Leung
Karen Corrigan
Kate Paesani
Katherine Appleby
Kathleen M. Ward
Keith Slater
Kristin Denham
Larry LaFond
Laura Downing
Laura McGarrity
Laurie Zaring
Lee Fullerton
Linguistica Occitana (www.revistadoc.org)
Linnaea Stockall
Lisa Davidson
Lisa Galvin
Lise Menn
Ljiljana Progovac
Luis Vicente
Maite Taboada
Margaret Dunham
Maria Iliescu
Mark Donohue
Mary Swift
Mary Zdrojkowski
Marya Teutsch-Dwyer
Mathias Schulze
Matthias Heinz
Michael Becker
Michael Cahill
Michael Lessard-Clouston
Michael Wagner
Mira Ariel
Nancy Frishberg
Nancy Niedzielski
Nancy Stenson
Nancy Underwood
Naomi Fox
Nicole Dehe
Nobuko Koyama-Murakami
Oliver Stegen
Patricia Donaher
PAUL JUSTICE
Peter Richtsmeier
Pier Marco Bertinetto
Regina Morin
Ricardo etxepare
Rick Nouwen
Robert Englebretson
Robert Hagiwara
Robert Williams
Roberta D'Alessandro
Roderick A. Jacobs
Rodrigo Gutiérrez-Bravo
Roland Pfau
Sarah Fish
Scott Jackson
Scott McGinnis
Seizi Iwata
Shamila Naidoo
Stanley Dubinsky
Student Linguistics Asso, the Ohio State University
Susan Fiksdal
Susan Windisch Brown
Susannah Levi
Susanne Gahl
Sven Grawunder
Taibi NOUR
Theresa Biberauer
Thor Sigurd Nilsen
Tom Roeper
Trudy Smoke
Veronika Koller
Virginia LoCastro
Wim Vandenbussche
Wolfgang J. Meyer
Yael Sharvit
Yoonjung Kang
- Plus 5 anonymous donors
DONORS (Up to $50)
Adam Buchwald
Adrienne Bruyn
Agnes Sandor
Albert Ortmann
Amina Mettouchi
Andrea Berez
Anja Steinlen
Ann Sawyer
Anne Reboul
Anne-Michelle Tessier
Betty Phillips
Bonny Sands
Brook Danielle Lillehaugen
Catharine Vollmer
Catherine Fortin
Cathryn Donohue
Catie Berkenfield
Chris Sams
Christel de Bruijn
Christopher Becker
David Gaatone
David Oshima
Della Chambless
Diana Apoussidou
Dimitrios Ntelitheos
Dipika Mukherjee
Donald F. Reindl
Donna Cromer
E. Allyn Smith
Eileen Smith
Elena Battaner-Moro
Elisabeth COTTIER FÁBIÁN
Erik Willis
Fay Wouk
George Williams
Hans Lindquist
Harry Feldman
Hedde Zeijlstra
Heike Zinsmeister
Helen Stickney
Istvan Kecskes
Jacques Jayez
Janet M. Smith
Janice Boynton
Janneke ter Beek
Jason Whitt
Jean-Marc Dewaele
Jesse Mortelmans
John Beavers
Jon Brennan
Jonathan Glenn
Jorge E Porras
Josep Alba
Joshua Viau
Judith Pine
Judith Tonhauser
Karl Reinhardt
Kat Dziwirek
katherine martinez
Katja Jasinskaja
Keir Moulton
Keira Gebbie Ballantyne
Kent Johnson
Kevin Bretonnel Cohen
Koscielecki Marek
Laurie Poulson
Lawrence Rosenwald
Levinson
Lilia Ruiz Debbe
Linda Apse
Lise Dobrin
Lotus Goldberg
Lynsey Wolter
M Victoria Vazquez Rozas
Magnús Snædal
Maher Awad
Mai Kuha
Marek Koscielecki
Margot Rozendaal
Marian Sloboda
Martin Warin
Mary Paster
Maurice Wong
Max Wheeler
Mayrene Bentley
Michael Maxwell
Michael Pickering
Michelle Fullwood
Miguel Ayerbe
Mike Matloff
Mohammad Haji-Abdolhosseini
Mohammad Jaber
Nancy Stern
Nicholas Fleisher
Olga Gurevich
Pamela Jordan
Peter Slomanson
Pierre Francois Cintas
Rachel Fournier
Raffaella Zanuttini and Bob Frank
Randall Gess
Richard Winters
Robert Port
Ron Schaefer
Ronald Schaefer
Sadie Williams
Sandra W. Smith
Sebastian Rasinger
Sergio Baauw
Sherril Condon
Shih-Jen Huang
Shlomo Izre'el
Sonya Bird
Stefan Dollinger
Stefan Frisch
Steven Hartman-Keiser
Sumayya Racy
Susan D Fischer
Tamina Stephenson
Tania Zamuner
Thera Crane
Theres Grueter
Tomohiro Yanagi
Ute Smit
V J Fedson
Valeria Quochi
Vera Demberg
Vivienne Rogers
Walcir Cardoso
Will Fitzgerald
Winifred Davies
Xose Luis Regueira-Fernandez
Yosuke Sato
Yuri & Mio Backhaus
- Plus 19 anonymous donors
******************************************************
MAJOR SUPPORTING PUBLISHERS
Blackwell Publishing
http://www.blackwellpublishing.com
Cambridge University Press
http://us.cambridge.org
Cascadilla Press
http://www.cascadilla.com/
Continuum International Publishing Group Ltd
http://www.continuumbooks.com
Edinburgh University Press
http://www.eup.ed.ac.uk/
European Language Resources Association
http://www.elda.org/sommaire.php
Georgetown University Press
http://www.press.georgetown.edu
Hodder Arnold
http://www.hoddereducation.co.uk
John Benjamins
http://www.benjamins.com/
http://www.benjamins.nl/
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
http://www.erlbaum.com/
Lincom GmbH
http://www.lincom.at
www.lincom.at
MIT Press
http://mitpress.mit.edu/
Mouton de Gruyter
http://www.mouton-publishers.com
Multilingual Matters
http://www.multilingual-matters.com/
Oxford University Press
http://www.oup.com/us
http://www.oup.co.uk
Palgrave Macmillan
http://www.palgrave.com
Rodopi
http://www.rodopi.nl/
Routledge (Taylor and Francis)
http://www.routledge.com/
Springer
http://www.springeronline.com
OTHER SUPPORTING PUBLISHERS
Anthropological Linguistics
http://www.indiana.edu/~anthling/
CSLI Publications
http://cslipublications.stanford.edu/
Graduate Linguistic Students' Assoc. Umass
http://glsa.hypermart.net/
International Pragmatics Assoc.
http://ipra-www.uia.ac.be/ipra/
Kingston Press Ltd
http://www.kingstonpress.com/
Linguistic Assoc. of Finland
http://www.ling.helsinki.fi/sky/
MIT Working Papers in Linguistics
http://web.mit.edu/mitwpl/
Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics / Landelijke
http://www.lotpublications.nl/
Pacific Linguistics
http://pacling.anu.edu.au/
SIL International
http://www.ethnologue.com/bookstore.asp
St. Jerome Publishing Ltd.
http://www.stjerome.co.uk
Utrecht institute of Linguistics
http://www-uilots.let.uu.nl/
******************************************************
INSTITUTIONS
Aptima, Inc.
Arizona State University
Bilkent University
Birkbeck, University of London
Bucknell University
CACI International Inc.
City University of Hong Kong
Concordia University
DarthDex
Dictaphone
Dublin City University
EML Research gGmbH
European Academy Bozen/Bolzano
European Bioinformatics Institute
European Science Foundation ESF
Franklin Electronic Publishers, Inc.
Gallaudet University
Georgetown University
H5 Technologies
Harvard University Institute of English Language
International Linguistic Association
Janya Inc.
Language Analysis Systems, Inc.
Lund University
McGill University
Michigan State University
Microsoft Corporation
National Security Agency
National Tsing Hua University
North-West University
Northeastern Illinois University
Northwestern University
OFAI - Austrian Research Inst. for AI
Priberam Informática
Rozetta
Simon Fraser University
Stanford University
SVOX AG
Swarthmore College
SYSTRAN Software Inc.
Szanca Solutions, Inc.
Thomson Legal & Regulatory
Tufts University
UCLA
Universitaet Konstanz
Universitaet Leipzig
University of Alberta
University of British Columbia
University of Calgary
University of Cambridge
University of Chicago
University of Cincinnati
University of Cyprus
University of Edinburgh
University of Florida
University of Fribourg, Suisse
University of Geneva - ETI
University of Goettingen
University of Hamburg
University of Heidelberg
University of Helsinki
University of Illinois
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC)
University of Konstanz
University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban
University of Leipzig
University of Maryland
University of Maryland, College Park
University of Melbourne
University of Michigan
University of Oregon
University of Pittsburgh
University of Potsdam
University of Reading
University of Rochester
University of Southampton
University of Southern Denmark
University of Texas at Austin
University of Victoria
Universität Tübingen
Université de Neuchâtel
Université du Québec à Montréal
Voice Signal Technologies
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
-----------------------------------------------------------
LINGUIST List: Vol-17-1024
More information about the LINGUIST
mailing list