36.727, Reviews: Linguistics: An Introduction: Sams (2025)

[The LINGUIST List]

LINGUIST List: Vol-36-727. Thu Feb 27 2025. ISSN: 1069 - 4875.

Subject: 36.727, Reviews: Linguistics: An Introduction: Sams (2025)

Moderator: Steven Moran (linguist at linguistlist.org)
Managing Editor: Justin Fuller
Team: Helen Aristar-Dry, Steven Franks, Joel Jenkins, Daniel Swanson, Erin Steitz
Jobs: jobs at linguistlist.org | Conferences: callconf at linguistlist.org | Pubs: pubs at linguistlist.org

Homepage: http://linguistlist.org

Editor for this issue: Joel Jenkins <joel at linguistlist.org>

================================================================


Date: 27-Feb-2025
From: Christopher D. Sams [samsc at sfasu.edu]
Subject: Applied Linguistics, General Linguistics: Sams (2025)


Book announced at https://linguistlist.org/issues/35-2400

Title: Linguistics: An Introduction
Publication Year: 2024

Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing
           http://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/
Book URL:
https://www.bloomsbury.com/linguistics-an-introduction-9781350164253/

Author(s): William B McGregor

Reviewer: Christopher D. Sams

SUMMARY
Linguistics: An Introduction 3rd edition by William B. McGregor is a
textbook aimed at presenting linguistics in a way to “stimulate [the
reader’s] understanding of the subject, rather than encourage mere
rote memorization of facts” (Preface). McGregor goes on in the preface
to explain that he wrote the first edition to reflect his preferred
“manner of presentation, pedagogic philosophy, [and] the range and
type of information presented and theoretical stance”. At the
beginning of the book, in a section entitled ‘Notes on the Text’
(xiii), he clarifies his purpose in more depth. In addition, an
‘Introduction’ and lists of ‘Figures’, ‘Maps’, and ‘Tables’ are
included  prior to Chapter 1.
Each chapter (including the introduction) begins with a brief synopsis
of the material presented, the main goals of the chapter, and a box
containing ‘Key terms’. At the end of the chapter, there are sections
on  ‘Summing up’, ‘Guide to further reading’, ‘Issues for further
thought and exercises’, and ‘Research projects’.
There are 17 chapters in total divided into four parts.
Part I ‘Language: System and Structure’ is comprised of Chapter 2
‘Sounds of Language: Phonetics and Phonology’, Chapter 3 ‘Structure of
Words: Morphology’, Chapter 4 ‘Lexicon’, Chapter 5 ‘Structure of
Sentences: Syntax’ and Chapter 6 ‘Meaning’.
Part II Language in Use includes Chapters 7 ‘Sociolinguistics:
Language in Its Social Context’, Chapter 8 ‘Text and Discourse’, and
Chapter 9 ‘Investigating Language in Use: Corpus Linguistics’.
Part III Language: A Human Phenomenon is comprised of Chapter 10
‘Language in Its Biological Context’, Chapter 11 ‘Psycholinguistics:
Language, the Mind and the Brain’, and Chapter 12 ‘Language Learning’.
Part IV Language: Uniformity and Diversity includes Chapters 13 ‘Sign
Languages’,  Chapter 14 ‘Writing’,  Chapter 15 ‘Unity and Diversity in
Language Structure’, Chapter 16 ‘Language Change’, and Chapter 17
‘Languages of the World’.
The end of the book contains a glossary, notes, an extensive (21
pages) list of references, and language, name, and subject indices.
The textbook is organized with each topic within a chapter receiving
its own clearly labeled section. The sections follow a logical order
e.g., Chapter 2 builds from articulatory phonetics, to acoustic
phonetics, to suprasegmental features, and finally to phonology. The
textbook utilizes the standardized International Phonetic Alphabet
(IPA) and follows the Leipzig glossing rules. Each chapter is quite
comprehensive for use in an introductory linguistics course; it makes
no assumptions regarding prior knowledge of linguistics in its
treatment which makes it accessible to introductory students. From the
perspective of a  teacher using this textbook, students can access
what they ‘need’ to know, but it is exceedingly comprehensive in that
the student can keep digging deeper into each chapter through the
reflection questions that are integrated into the text, ‘Guide to
further reading’, ‘Issues for further thought and exercises’, and
‘Research projects’. The exercises use a typologically diverse
selection of languages, the majority of which are non-Indo-European.
All of the exercises tend to be at the same difficulty - there doesn’t
appear to be a hierarchy of complexity. Compared to other introductory
textbooks, there are fewer exercises in some chapters e.g., there are
20 words and five sentences for transcription practice and four
phonology problems in Chapter 2. In Chapter 3, there is a passage to
break down words into morphemes (rather than the list of words
“controlled” for complexity and discussion found in many introductory
textbooks) and five morphological data sets. Chapter 5 contains tree
diagrams, but there seems to be an imbalance in the quality and
quantity in how formalism is treated. Terms such as ‘movability’ and
‘contractibility’’ are used rather than the more traditional
‘constituency’ and ‘replacement’. Chapter 5 covers a significant
amount of material from clause and phrase structure to grammatical
relations. At numerous points it raises concerns about formal syntax
that may be intended to show students that there are theoretical
issues but that also may at times confuse them, since it may not
specifically refer to alternatives e.g., there are no references to
Head-Driven Phrase Structure (HPSG) Grammar, Lexical-Functional
Grammar (LFG), or Role and Reference Grammar (RRG).
Parts II, II, and IV appear much more even in their treatment of
various theories. Chapter 8 ‘Text and Discourse’ is particularly
strong in its treatment of Conversation and Discourse Analysis; and
Chapter 9 ‘Investigating Language in Use: Corpus Linguistics’ is
notably comprehensive. Chapters 10 ‘Language in Its Biological
Context’ and Chapter 11 ‘Psycholinguistics: Language, the Mind and the
Brain’ both give a broad overview of human language vs animal
communication, thought (as a philosophical construct), and the brain.
However, Chapter 12 ‘Language Learning’ isn’t given as much attention
as in other introductory textbooks - nine pages to address first
language acquisition and three pages to address second language
acquisition - a large gap in the textbook. Instructors using this
textbook will likely need to bring in other materials to ensure a
holistic treatment of first and second language learning. Chapters 13
‘Sign Languages’ and Chapter 14 ‘Writing’ give ample treatment to sign
language (not limited to American Sign Language) and Chapter 14 gives
a sufficient overview of writing systems. Chapter 15 ‘Unity and
Diversity in Language Structure’ gives a thorough treatment of
linguistic typology covering phonological, morphological, and
syntactic typology. Chapter 16 ‘Language Change’ is comprehensive in
its coverage of historical linguistics.
EVALUATION
The textbook itself is extremely well organized and presented. It is
quite easy to navigate and could be used by someone looking to learn
more about linguistics, as well as by a student using it as a textbook
for an introductory course in linguistics. In terms of presentation, I
think the textbook would benefit from footnotes as opposed to endnotes
(I know many students say they don’t take the time to flip or scroll
to the end of the book to see the notes. However, I know endnotes are
commonly required by style manuals and publishers.)  I think the book
would also benefit from moving the ‘Key Terms’ from the beginning of
each chapter to the end. I quickly surveyed several textbooks in
linguistics and this convention seems to be quite common. Having the
terms at the beginning can prime the reader for what to watch out for,
but at the same time it could intimidate them. Relocating the ‘Key
Terms’ to the end of each chapter would allow the reader to look at
each term and ensure comprehension. It is refreshing to see so many
languages represented in the examples used in the textbook (the
language index is five pages long and is typologically diverse). Many
textbooks tend to focus only on Indo-European language data.
In terms of pedagogy, one of the main highlights is the textbook
author’s aim to promote higher-order thinking skills and critical
thinking. His aim is to have active readers and thinkers that go
beyond surface-level thinking to the application of what they have
learned to correlating and synthesizing the material. This goal is
accomplished throughout the textbook by adding gray boxes where the
author asks the reader to reflect, sections on  ‘Issues for further
thought,” exercises at the end of each chapter, and the suggested
‘Research project’. These sections would make the textbook quite easy
for instructors to adapt.
In addition, there is a companion website that contains a phenomenal
amount of information. from a brief explanation of the language of
text messaging to the author’s advice on essay writing. There are also
great exercises for the reader.  The website is invaluable to both the
reader and the instructor. There is a link for ‘Lecturer resources,’
and each chapter has a ‘Test your knowledge of this chapter’ quiz. In
sum, this textbook can accommodate students with different levels of
interest and will promote genuine intellectual curiosity. It also
teaches the scientific method, admitting that sometimes linguists have
hypotheses that are not supported by the data and that, in other
instances, an explanation may be improved, e.g., by explaining more of
the data or addressing exceptions.
The author is committed to revision and self-evaluation, stating that
in past editions there were “…a few instances where I uncritically
repeated widespread linguistic myths” (xvi). He also notes in ‘About
the third edition’ that in Chapter 12, this edition uses the term
language ‘learning’ rather than language ‘acquisition’, as these are
two extremely different concepts in the field (p. xvi).
The author is mostly successful in his attempts to remain as theory
neutral as possible, though I feel that there is an imbalance in that
formalism isn’t given as much attention as other mainstream theories.
William McGregor is the driving force behind ‘Semiotic Grammar,’ and
he explicitly points out on page xiv that “While I have my own
minority theoretical perspective [Semiotic Grammar], I do not attempt
to present or argue it here; rather I stand back from it, and adopt a
more general stance that includes many theories within the so-called
functionalist, usage-based and cognitivist paradigms.” He exposes
readers to both formal and functional approaches and presents both
older and newer treatments, but at times the balance seems uneven
since his aim is not to “adopt the dominant theoretical framework in
linguistics, generative grammar” (xiv). On page 17 he devotes about a
third of the page to generative grammar. In the chapter ‘Structure of
Sentences: Syntax’, syntactic trees are addressed and there are
example sentences for students to try their hand at drawing trees, but
although the author mentions that Chomsky’s theories have evolved over
the years, there is no explicit mention of Government and Binding,
Principles and Parameters, or X-bar theory.  Given its status in our
field, generative grammar could have been given more attention.
Another weakness in the textbook is the sparse treatment of second
language acquisition (SLA) in Chapter 12. As mentioned above, in this
edition the author has adopted the term ‘learning’ to “align [himself]
with a constructivist approach to language learning” (xvi). He
acknowledges that ‘learning’ and ‘acquisition’ have distinct meanings
in linguistics but devotes only three pages to SLA. Many students
using this book are likely also lovers of language learning, and it
would be useful if this were expanded significantly to include work
from Ellis, Krashen, MacWhinney, and VanPatten – just to name a few.
The textbook is quite comprehensive in covering what other textbooks
miss, such as typology and universals and writing systems and texting.
However, the textbook makes no mention of forensic linguistics despite
its being included in more and more introductory textbooks on the
market today.  On page 21, there is a non-comprehensive list of
branches of linguistics that aren’t covered in the book, and forensic
linguistics isn’t even mentioned in passing there.
ABOUT THE REVIEWER
Chris Sams is a Professor of Linguistics at Stephen F. Austin State
University in Texas. His research and teaching interests are second
language acquisition, forensic linguistics, linguistic typology and
universals, language description and documentation, Romance
linguistics, and historical linguistics.



------------------------------------------------------------------------------

********************** LINGUIST List Support ***********************
Please consider donating to the Linguist List to support the student editors:

https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=87C2AXTVC4PP8

LINGUIST List is supported by the following publishers:

Bloomsbury Publishing http://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/

Cambridge University Press http://www.cambridge.org/linguistics

Cascadilla Press http://www.cascadilla.com/

De Gruyter Mouton https://cloud.newsletter.degruyter.com/mouton

Elsevier Ltd http://www.elsevier.com/linguistics

John Benjamins http://www.benjamins.com/

Language Science Press http://langsci-press.org

Multilingual Matters http://www.multilingual-matters.com/

Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics / Landelijke (LOT) http://www.lotpublications.nl/

Oxford University Press http://www.oup.com/us

Wiley http://www.wiley.com


----------------------------------------------------------
LINGUIST List: Vol-36-727
----------------------------------------------------------