Moctezuma exhibit at British Museum
John F. Schwaller
schwallr at potsdam.edu
Wed Apr 8 14:19:17 UTC 2009
Date: 7 Apr 2009
From: "michael ruggeri" <michaelruggeri at mac.com>
Listeros,
Erik Boot has an extensive posting on the Moctezuma exhibit opening at
the British Museum in September. I am reproducing his posts for you
here;
Ancient MesoAmerica News Updates 2009, No. 8: London, England - More
Information on the Upcoming Exhibition "Moctezuma" at The British Museum
Today, Tuesday April 7, 2009, the online edition of the daily British
newspaper The Telegraph posted an extensive note on the upcoming
exhibition entitled "Moctezuma: Aztec Ruler" at The British Museum.
The exhibition will be shown at the museum from September 25, 2009, to
January 24, 2010. It will feature an alternative rendering of the
final moments in the life of Moctezuma, supported by two small images
from 16th century manuscripts: He was killed by the Spaniards, not his
own people (edited by AMaNU) (photo: The Telegraph/AP: Aztec mosaic
mask, probably a potrait of Xiuhtecuhtli):
Moctezuma, last Aztec ruler 'was no traitor', British Museum
exhibition to claim - Moctezuma, the last ruler of the Aztec empire,
was not a traitor who sold out to the Spanish conquistadors, a new
British Museum exhibition will claim later this year. To date, history
has cast him as the man who ceded his empire to the Spanish in 1520
largely without a fight. However, evidence never before presented in
public in Britain will show that he was humiliated before his people
by being paraded in chains, supporting an alternative theory that
power was wrested from his grasp.
Two portraits from the 1560s will show that he was bound in chains and
rope before being paraded on a balcony. Colin McEwan, curator at the
British Museum, said it was likely that the conventional picture of
Moctezuma as a willing agent of colonial rule had been painted by the
Spanish victors.
He thought the version of events indicated by the 1560s manuscripts –
which were produced by indigenous scribes under Spanish patronage –
was "probably closer to what actually happened".
He argued: "Is it likely that a feared military ruler just completely
changes his complexion and weakly and willingly subjects himself to
ceding his empire to the Spanish? Is that plausible?"
Moctezuma came to power in 1502, ruling over one of the day's largest
and most advanced civilisations, which straddled much of Central
America from the Caribbean to the Pacific. While the Aztec empire was
at its zenith, its politics were fragile. Moctezuma consolidated power
by heavily taxing his subjects, in the form of raw materials or
precious art works. One such object is thought to be the turquoise,
gold foil and mother of pearl mask that will go on display in the
exhibition.
Consequently the Spanish found it easy to find high-powered enemies of
the emperor among his ranks, said Neil MacGregor, director of the
British Museum. He said: "What is so interesting is that this is an
empire that is at the top of its form when it falls. The way it was
constructed made it vulnerable because it made it easy for the Spanish
to recruit disaffected allies." Ironically, the lasting picture of
Moctezuma as a turncoat meant he has become more celebrated more in
Europe than in Mexico, noted Mr McEwan.
Moctezuma: Aztec Ruler, which opens in September, is the fourth and
last exhibition in a British Museum series about great historical
rulers. It began two years ago with The First Emperor, which brought a
small selection of China's Terracotta Army to London. That coup earned
the museum 850,000 visitors over seven months. Last summer Hadrian:
Empire and Conflict attracted 244,000 over three months while 50,000
have seen the third, about the Iranian ruler Shah Abbas, since it
opened in February (written by Stephen Adams; source Telegraph).
The British Museum now has a special website on which further
information, relevant to the exhibition, can be found: Moctezuma:
Aztec Ruler. It features, for instance, a link to the full press
release.
Another British newspaper, The Guardian, provided the following online
report on the upcoming exhibition (edited by AMaNU) (photo: The
Guardian/Museo de America, Madrid: Detail from Enconchado 16, by Juan
y Miguel Gonzalez, A.D. 1698, Moctezuma shown on the balcony):
New exhibition challenges view of Aztec emperor Moctezuma as traitor -
Contrary to popular belief, the Aztec emperor Moctezuma was murdered
by his Spanish captors and not by his own people, the British Museum
will argue in a new exhibition that will try to rehabilitate the
emperor's image as a traitor.
The exhibition will bring together spectacular loans from Europe,
where the Spanish conquistadors brought many of the Aztecs' greatest
treasures, and from Mexico, where recently excavated relics from the
lost civilisation continue to be found under its modern capital,
Mexico City. Scientific tests on objects including a spectacular
turquoise mask, from the British Museum's own collection, show that in
a single piece, the gold, precious stone and feather decorations were
drawn from many different places. "What we are trying to do is look at
an absolutely key moment in the history of the world through the
filter of one man," museum director Neil MacGregor said. "There has
never been an exhibition on this man, a great emperor of an extremely
sophisticated empire in ways which seemed very strange to European
eyes."
The traditional account of the death of Moctezuma – the museum has
adopted the spelling as closer to his name in his own Nahuatl language
than the more common Montezuma – is that having been taken a willing
hostage by Hernán Cortés and the conquistadors, he was killed by his
own outraged people.
According to several versions of the story, in 1520, the Spanish
brought him out onto a balcony of his own palace to try and calm the
riotous mob, but he was pelted with stones and killed. One Spanish
account, written years later, even insists that he refused medical
help and food from his Spanish captors, who "spoke very kindly to
him", before suddenly dying.
However, the exhibition will include two small images from later
manuscripts, one now in Glasgow, one in Mexico, both probably made by
Aztecs working for Spanish patrons, which show the leader distinctly
less kindly treated, brought out with a rope around his neck, or
shackled. Once the Aztecs began to revolt against the presence of the
Spanish in their capital city, Tenochtitlan, this version suggests,
Moctezuma was useless to them, so they killed him before just managing
to escape with their lives.
"Moctezuma is the last in our series on great rulers and their
legacies and presents perhaps one of the most fascinating examples of
implosion of power and the clash of civilisations," MacGregor said.
The series included China's first emperor, Qin, the Roman emperor
Hadrian, the wall builder, and the 16th-century Iranian ruler Shah
Abbas. While there were writings by, and many contemporary accounts
of, the characters, curator Colin McEwan admitted that authentic
personal details about Moctezuma are so scarce that one academic he
consulted said he thought the exhibition would be impossible.
"We will raise many questions but we may not succeed in answering them
all," Mc Ewan said. The exhibition, with a related show of 20th-
century revolutionary posters and images opening in October, with both
running into next year, will mark both the bicentenary of Mexico's
declaration of independence from Spain in 1810, and of the Mexican
Revolution 100 years later (written by Maev Kennedy; sourceThe
Guardian).
Mike Ruggeri
The British Museum Link on the Exhibit;
http://www.britishmuseum.org/whats_on/future_exhibitions/moctezuma.aspx
Erik Boot's Ancient Mesoamerican News Updates
http://ancient-mesoamerica-news-updates.blogspot.com/
Mike Ruggeri's Ancient America Museum Exhibitions, Conferences and
Lectures
http://tinyurl.com/c9mlao
_______________________________________________
Nahuatl mailing list
Nahuatl at lists.famsi.org
http://www.famsi.org/mailman/listinfo/nahuatl
More information about the Nahuat-l
mailing list