V. V. Putin's geopolitical catastrophe

[Max Pyziur]

> It's as if we are reading different texts. It reminds me of a story how
> three blind men described an elephant, one said - a wall, the other said a
> snake, the third said a column.
>
> A head of state is supposed to defend the rights of his own citizens

Citizens or ethnics?

> wherever they might be, even if POWs. We would attack him if he didn't. A
> leader's major address to the Parliament is usually about the state of the
> nation and the new directions of the nation, not about the state of
> minorities (and every country except for Iceland has manorities).

By comparison from Viktor Yushchenko's speech to the U.S. Congress on
April 6th:
"The Orange Revolution gave evidence that Ukraine is an advanced European
nation, sharing the great values of the Euro-Atlantic civilization. A
civil society has matured in Ukraine; its citizens stand ready to guard
their rights and freedoms. We Ukrainians are a diverse nation. We speak
different languages, we practice different religions, and we have
different political views. But we all recognize the right of each and
every individual to determine his or her faith. This recognition
underlines our unity and our strength."
http://eng.maidanua.org/node/249

MP
pyz at brama.com



> The catastrophe and the national question are just one line of a 16 page
> text. And to be sure it was a catastrophe for some, even for many. So was
> the desintegration of the British empire, or the French empire (the
> debates
> over Algiers are still going on, 40 years later.)
>
> But this is not what the speech is about. It is about "svoboda",
> "demokratija", "spravedlivost'", "pravo" "gosudarstvennost'" - these are
> the key word. Three paragraphs are devoted to corrupt bureaucracy, there
> are at least two mentions of curbing of state government power on the path
> to democracy. There is a section on economy and capital investment,
> several
> passages about law and morality, quite a bit about poverty, health,
> mortality and low birth. And it ends where it began: gosudarstvennost',
> spravedlivost', svoboda.
>
> As leaders' speeches go, this is a good one, full of honorable ideas and
> suggestion how to improve the country.
>
>
>>To view the manner in which Mr. Putin's remarks were presented in the
>>Ukrainian press, see:
>>http://www2.pravda.com.ua/archive/2005/april/25/news/20.shtml
>>
>>According to the remarks cited in this report, Mr Putin is concerned
>>with the rights of ethnic Russians who, as a result of the
>>USSR's breakup, find themselves outside of Russia.  Interestingly, he
>>fails to mention the rights
>>of the numerous non-Russians living within the Russian federation.
>>
>>A better politician would first enumerate what the Russian federation
>>is doing for the retention
>>of language and culture among its minorities, including those whose
>>roots are elsewhere and those
>>whose lands were conquered by the Russian empire.  If no such measures
>>are in place, the politician
>>would work toward introducing them. Having proposed a model worthy of
>>imitation,
>>the politician would request that the same be done for the Russian
>>minorities in today's independent countries.
>>
>>As things stand, Mr Putin lacks the moral authority to talk about
>>minority rights in the post-Soviet space.
>
>
> __________________________
>  Alina Israeli
>  LFS, American University
>  4400 Mass. Ave., NW
>  Washington, DC 20016
>
>  phone:    (202) 885-2387
>  fax:      (202) 885-1076
>
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
>  Use your web browser to search the archives, control your subscription
>   options, and more.  Visit and bookmark the SEELANGS Web Interface at:
>                     http://seelangs.home.comcast.net/
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
>

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Use your web browser to search the archives, control your subscription
  options, and more.  Visit and bookmark the SEELANGS Web Interface at:
                    http://seelangs.home.comcast.net/
-------------------------------------------------------------------------