What Bloomfield said.

[Rankin, Robert L.]

Thanks for looking that up, Dave!  I'd have had to hobble to the University library as Algonquian materials are not part of my personal library.  I used to quote that passage to my Field Methods classes, and it always got a good laugh when I got to the celibacy part.

Bob
________________________________
From: Siouan Linguistics [SIOUAN at listserv.unl.edu] on behalf of David Costa [pankihtamwa at EARTHLINK.NET]
Sent: Monday, May 13, 2013 2:46 PM
To: SIOUAN at listserv.unl.edu
Subject: Re: What Bloomfield said.

Hockett in the intro to Bloomfield's Menominee grammar, page vii:

"Bloomfield was speaking of the tremendous difficulty of obtaining a really adequate of any language, and suggested, half humorously, that linguists dedicated to this task should not get married, nor teach: instead they should take a vow of celibacy, spend as long a summer as feasible each year in the field, and spend the winter collating and filing the material. With this degree of intensiveness, Bloomfield suggested, a linguist could perhaps produce good accounts of three languages in his lifetime".

I should point out that Bloomfield didn't do this much, either.

Dave


> Don't feel too bad about this. As Bloomfield famously said, it is almost impossible to document one language in a lifetime, and you have documented two.

Let me paraphrase what Bloomfield actually said, since I'd have to go to the library to get the exact wording:  If a linguist devotes every Summer to collecting field data and every Winter to processing those data, AND REMAINS CELIBATE, he may "turn to account three languages" in a lifetime.

Needless to say, I'm not even closing in on two.

Bob

P.S. If I recollect rightly, the original Bloomfield passage is from the introduction to his Menominee Grammar (but I could be corrected on the source.  It could be the Ojibwa grammar and the quote could be Hockett quoting Bloomfield.).

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listserv.linguistlist.org/pipermail/siouan/attachments/20130513/787af173/attachment.htm>