productive/receptive writing question

Erika erhoffma at OBERLIN.EDU
Mon Aug 12 21:15:42 UTC 2013

Thanks Charles!

Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 12, 2013, at 4:34 PM, "Charles Butler" <chazzer3332000 at YAHOO.COM> wrote:

> Erika, 
> I use both methods. If I'm transcribing someone, I prefer to write what I see. It was how I was taught. That way I mark exactly what the other person is doing, how I see it, with the right hand on the left side, and the left hand on the right side. 
> If one is showing a video, I would prefer to have the SignWriting if it is next to it be receptive as well, then one can lay down the SignWriting directly on the photograph and it matches, it is not mirror-image reversed front to back. 
> This reads right to left for a right hand signer when one is writing it. One's right hand is to the left. 
> When I am watching a video, I have to write it that way first and then translate it sign-for-sign. I learned ASL in the 1970s and SignWriting in the 1980s.
> I understand the desire for writing what one is doing oneself, but when I see a video, it is next to impossible for me to reverse everything to write it down the first time. 
> Charles Butler
> chazzer3332000 at
> 240-764-5748
> Clear writing moves business forward.
> From: Erika Hoffmann-Dilloway <erhoffma at OBERLIN.EDU>
> Sent: Monday, August 12, 2013 2:39 PM
> Subject: productive/receptive writing question
> Hi everyone! I'm going to be giving a paper at our annual anthropology meetings this fall on a panel about how to best represent visual aspects of linguistic phenomena. 
> I want to talk about the shift from receptive to productive writing in SW. I'm going to suggest that there are interesting theoretical and methodological lessons in this shift for scholars who want to transcribe visual aspects of communication, even if they aren't using SW per se (though I also want to make more scholars in my field aware of how useful SW can be for this purpose).
> To that end, I was wondering if list members might be willing to talk with me about their feelings about productive writing with SW. Did you initially write receptively? If so, how did you shift? (or do you still write receptively sometimes?). How do you feel that writing productively affects the way you choose to write (or how you read other people's writing)? 
> I'd love to hear answers to these questions and anything else you think is relevant about this aspect of SW, particularly as it relates to  your own ways of using the writing system (for teaching, for research, for translation, for poetry, etc). 
> The conference isn't until November, but I wanted to get started on it now, before the semester kicks in!
> Best,
> Erika
> -- 
> Erika Hoffmann-Dilloway
> Assistant Professor of Anthropology
> Oberlin College
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <>

More information about the Sw-l mailing list