rankin at ku.edu
Wed Nov 24 15:30:41 UTC 2004
There seem to be Mandan and Biloxi cognates, but, as John says, there are
interesting irregularities. *kyetaN seems to be composed of at least two and
perhaps more morphemes. It represents a medium-sized hawk or falcon (Buteo).
There is another word for the largest hawk, tho', as I recall, it too has the
rare *ky cluster. From my own point of view, ANY Siouan stem that begins with a
*kC cluster is liable to be historically bimorphemic. K-clusters are inherently
suspicious in Siouan as there are so many different prefixes in K that tend to
lose vowels by syncope and form clusters.
We don't seem to have Crow or Hidatsa cognates for the 'hawk' sets, so
proto-Siouan could be questioned, but the Biloxi and Mandan forms make it very
old, however far back that takes us. Crow and Hidatsa are probably worth
----- Original Message -----
From: "David Costa" <pankihtamwa at earthlink.net>
To: <siouan at lists.colorado.edu>; <siouan at lists.colorado.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, November 23, 2004 6:18 PM
Subject: Re: bird.
> Can *kyetaN be reconstructed all the way back to Proto-Siouan, or only
> Proto-Mississippi Valley?
>> On Tue, 23 Nov 2004, Michael Mccafferty wrote:
>>> Dave Costa has pointed out that its PA */kenliwa/ and Fox /ketiwa/.
>> So we're comparing something like
>> Fox ke tiwa
>> P(MV?)S *kyetaN
>> PA *kenliwa
>> P(MV?)S *kyetaN
>> That's a little more different than usual. The Siouan set is slightly
>> irregular, in that Dakota varies a bit in whether it exhibits Cc^ or c^h
>> for *Cy. For example, Da (wi)kc^emna[N] : OP *gdheb(dh)aN 'ten', but Da
>> c^hetaH : OP gdhedaN 'hawk'. In both cases initial *kye- is apparently
>> involved. There are a certain number of these *Cy sets, however. Two
>> others I recall offhand are *pyaphaNk- 'mosquito' and *e-p-ye 'I think'.
>> I seem to recall that there's another *ky in another 'bird' set.
>> Note, on 'ten': OP has gdhebdhaN 'ten' in old word lists, but in Dorsey
>> and later there's only gdhebaN.
More information about the Siouan