Croque madame and [an]arthrocity

[Joel S. Berson]

At 12/3/2007 08:43 PM, Arnold M. Zwicky wrote:
>On Dec 3, 2007, at 5:01 PM, Joel Berson wrote:
>
>>At 12/3/2007 03:41 PM, Arnold M. Zwicky wrote:
>>>...  (i see that "croque monsieur" and
>>>"souvlaki" have made the cut.)
>>
>>But not "croque madame".  Is there still gender bias in the OED?  (As
>>well as on the web: 77,000 Google hits -- including, he said
>>arthrously,* The Wikipedia -- compared with 637,000 for "croque
>>monsieur".)
>
>well, "croque monsieur" came first, and "croque madame" was a play on
>it.

But, as some say, it's not transparent.  Who would deduce the egg on
top, not part of a croque monsieur?



>>* Not in OED3, nor is "arthrous".  Do I have an antedating?
>
>oh wow.  i hadn't thought to check.  i first recall reading this in
>mike and bea hall's 1970 paper entitled "A problem in rule ordering:
>Anarthrous locatives in Yiddish". [for bibliographers: R.M.R. &
>Beatrice Hall; i first met them in, omigod, 1964.]

OED3 needs to broaden its definition.  anarthrous:  "1. Of Greek ns.:
Used without the article."  The only quotations are about the Greek
language.  (The single quotation for "anarthrousness" seems unclear
about what language the "commonest terms" of Christianity were being
expressed in.)


>>>... (the only google hit i got for "domozoic" was a website
>>>claiming to
>>>trace the Levitical prohibition against eating shellfish to the
>>>possibility of poisoning by domozoic acid.  i am dubious.)
>>
>>"The reason is not explained in the Tora."  Alfred J. Kolatch, _The
>>Jewish Book of Why_ (1981), p. 89.
>
>people are forever trying to explain the levitical prohibitions
>against certain foods on an entrely rational basis.  while i'm not
>willing to go all the way on explanations that turn on rather high-
>level cultural assumptions, i think there's a lot in them.  but of
>course the Tora(h) isn't going to explain; unclean is unclean.

I don't have access to the "some say, others say" literature.

Joel

------------------------------------------------------------
The American Dialect Society - http://www.americandialect.org