[Lexicog] Sort order problem

[Paula Jones]

Dear Wayne & Greg, 

I am sorry I don't have time to read all of the correspondence carefully. I will just add the following - 
>From Dictionaries: the art and craft of lexicography, Sidney Landau 

p.107

 

ALPHABETIZATION - Dictionaries usually alphabetize letter by letter rather than word by word. They place power, powerful, and power of attorney in that order, whereas a word-by-word arrangement would place power of attorney before powerful. Letter-by-letter arrangement has the great virtue that readers need not know whether a compound is spelled as one word, as a hyphenated word, or as two words. Since usage is often divided about compounds - witness database and data base, e-mail and email - and is constantly shifting, the ability to locate such terms is of considerable practical importance.



When I read this, even though it is written regarding English dictionaries, it gave me the incentive to ask about changing the sort order for Eduria & Barasano, Eastern Tucanoan, which has a confusing mixup of word-breaks that we have tried to make more consistent based on meaning (i.e. if the part separated by a space has no meaning, it is combined) that the speakers agree with most of the time but there are cases where they want the space based on the phonetics. This inconsistency caused us to lean toward a sort order that ignores the spaces or work breaks. Also, the subentry system the speakers desire also fed into this, but I won't give the details on that. When I asked about changing, I was told to put a _ where there was a space / word break in the \lx field and to add it to the sort order properties to be ignored. I am sure it is not the best way to do it (did some by hand and others in Note Pad), but this change has caused the Eduria & Barasana to be much happier with the sort order, though that may be the change in the subentry organization that was done at the same time. Paula S. Jones







  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Wayne Leman 
  To: lexicographylist at yahoogroups.com 
  Sent: Thursday, March 09, 2006 1:23 AM
  Subject: [Lexicog] Sort order problem


  Greg, FWIW, I don't know if there is any lexicographical rationale for computer sort orders, such as having <space> float to the top. There's probably some rationale, but whatever it is comes from computer people. As you probably know, having <space> and punctuation marks and number before letters is what is called an ASCII sort, which just refers to the default way that computers sort. Of course, they have been programmed to sort that way. (Side thought: If people stopping programming that way for computers, they would be out of sorts, so to speak, of course!!)

  I'm just glad that we can modify sort orders as much as we can with some lexicography programs. It would be too bad if we always had to accept whatever order computer sorted words into.

  I'm not out of sorts now, but out of time,
  it's time to hit the sack,
  Wayne
  -----
  Wayne Leman
  Cheyenne website: http://www.geocities.com/cheyenne_language
    Wayne,

    I have not gotten either Toolbox or LexiquePro to ignore spaces. However I am also interested in understanding the rationale for adopting a given sort order.

    I assume Toolbox and LexiquePro users usually sort with spaces sorted to the top of the list.
    Thus the order: child, child care, child restraint, childish, children.
    This rationale is that entries involving the simplest form of the word take precedence over others.

    I have been advised to sort ignoring the space.
    Thus the sort order: child, child care, childish, children, child restraint.
    The rationale for this order is that it is strictly alphabetical. 

    Another possibility is too sort with the space at the bottom.
    Thus the sort order: child, childish, children, child care, child restraint.
    The rationale for this order is that all morphological forms of the head word take precedence over phrasal forms.

    Is there a preferred rationale and sort order in the world of lexicography?

    Regards, Greg


  SPONSORED LINKS Science kits  Science education  Science kit for kid  
        Cognitive science  Science education supply  My first science kit  


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS 

    a..  Visit your group "lexicographylist" on the web.
      
    b..  To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
     lexicographylist-unsubscribe at yahoogroups.com
      
    c..  Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. 


------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listserv.linguistlist.org/pipermail/lexicography/attachments/20060310/aeb92535/attachment.htm>