positive polarity operators and existence
Pål Kristian Eriksen
p.k.eriksen at ILF.UIO.NO
Fri Jan 17 13:15:33 UTC 2003
In Basque there is a prefix, ba-, which has a puzzling double
function. It can primarily be analysed as a type of positive polarity
operator which is prefixed to the finite verb when the sentence counters a
previously made negative proposition:
1) Ez du sagarr-a ja-n ume-a-k
NEG have.PRES.3sgSUB.3sgOBJ apple-ART eat-PERFPART kid-ART-ERG
"The kid hasn't eaten the apple"
2) Ba-du sagarr-a ja-n ume-a-k
Ba-have.PRES.3sgSUB.3sgOBJ apple-ART eat-PERFPART kid-ART-ERG
"The kid has indeed / in fact / so eaten the apple!"
The sentence in 2) is used to counter the negative proposition made in
1), thus ba- appears in the polarity operator position to the left of the
finite auxiliary. (See Laka, Itziar, 1994, "On the Syntax of Negation" for
an analysis of Basque polarity operators and polarity nodes)
However, ba- is also licensed in existential sentences (3)), without
forcing any stress on the sentence's positive polarity as seen in 2).
3) Ba-da txakurr-a ortu-a-n
Ba-be.PRES.3.sgSUB dog-ART garden-ART-LOC
"There is a dog in the garden"
Negative existential sentences simply substitute ba- with the negative
operator ez: (The subject is furthermore set in the partitive case, but
that is irrelevant to the current discussion)
4) Ez da txakurr-ik ortu-a-n
NEG be.PRES.3sgSUB dog-PART garden-ART-LOC
"There isn't any dog in the garden"
My question is if you are aware of other languages in which a positive
polarity operator has this additional function. I would also like to know
if there are languages in which such positive operators are used in forming
expressions of perfect tense and / or non-evidentiality (irrespective of
whether the operators appear in existential sentences or not). I will
summarise any interesting results for the list.
Thanks in advance,
Pål Kr. Eriksen
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Lingtyp