Siouan ki- 'become (again)', 'return to'

[shokooh Ingham]

I wonder whether vertative and possessive could not be the same in origin in that it expresses some prior relationship between the subject/actor of the verb and the object of the verb with possessive  and the destination in the case of a vertative.  The gl- form of the prefix occurs in both as in gluha, gluza 'have ones own, hold one's own' and gli 'arrive back' and gla 'go back'.
Bruce

ROOD DAVID S <David.Rood at Colorado.EDU> wrote: 
Jan, that's how I interpreted Bob's suggestion that the -ki- 'revert; 
become' is historically related to the -ki- of the vertatives, and 
distinct from any of the others.  I think we're saying that the morpheme 
in the vertatives is NOT the possessive.  But Bob will have to supply the 
cross-linguistic data for that.

David S. Rood
Dept. of Linguistics
Univ. of Colorado
295 UCB
Boulder, CO 80309-0295
USA
rood at colorado.edu

On Thu, 13 Dec 2007, Jan Ullrich wrote:

>
>> I'm going to side with Bob on this one.  It seems to me that the basic
>
>> meaning of the vertatives is not 'toward home' but 'back (again)'.
> Over
>> and over in the texts we read "i na gli na...." -- 'went there and
> came
>> back and...' without the concept of 'home' anywhere around.
>
> I fully agree that the vertitives mean "back" rather than "home". I
> didn't think that was in contradiction to the possessive analysis that I
> sided with, but perhaps it is.
> Or are you suggesting that the ki- that potentially formed the
> vertitives is the same ki- 'return back to the original state"?
> I might be missing some e-mails from this thread as it seems my spam
> filter has been acting up lately.
>
>> Allan had an explanation for khi but I've forgotten it -- and I can't
> put
>> my hands on the paper right now, either.  Bob?
>
> Would be good to know.
>
> Jan
>


       
---------------------------------
 Support the World Aids Awareness campaign this month with Yahoo! for Good
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listserv.linguistlist.org/pipermail/siouan/attachments/20071215/a0662d98/attachment.htm>