Reference question

[Andrew Carnie]

Many thanks! :)

A
On Mon, 13 Feb 2006, Shalom Lappin wrote:

> I believe it was McCawley (1968) (*McCawley*, J.: 1968, Concerning the
> Base Component of a Transformational Grammar. Foundations of Language,
> 4, pp. 55- 81. ). Bottom projection of phrase structure is formalized
> and implemented in left corner
> *McCawley*, J.D. 1967 Concerning the base component of a trans-
> formational grammar.
> /Foundations of Language, /
> Vol. 4. Reprint-
> ed in *McCawley*, J.D.,
> /Grammar and Meaning, /
> Academic Press,
> New York, NY, 1968.
> Peters, S. 1980 (Talk presented at the Workshop on Alternatives
> to Transformation Grammars, Stanford University, January.)
> Peters, S. and Ritchie, R.W. 1969 Context-sensitive immediate
> constituent analysis.
> /Proc. ACM Symposium on Theory of /
> /Computing. /
> Sager, N. 1967 Syntactic analysis of natural languages.
> /Advances /
> /in Computers, Vol. 8 /
> ed. M. Alt and M. Rubinoff, Academic
> Press, New York, NY.
> /Aravind K. Joshi is a professor of computer and /
> /information science, and that department's chairman, at /
> /the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. He re- /
> /ceived the Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering from /
> /the University of Pennsylvania in 1960. /
> /Leon S. Levy is a member of the technical staff of /
> /Bell Telephone Laboratories at Whippany, New Jersey. /
> /He received the Ph.D. degree in Computer Science from /
> /the University of Pennsylvania in 1970./
> parsing (discussion and references in, for example, Pereira and Shieber
> (1987), and Gazdar and Mellish (1989). Regards.
>                                        Shalom
> *** *
> 11
>
>
> Andrew Carnie wrote:
>
> >Hi All,
> >
> >I'm totally blanking on a reference here, who was it (and where was it)
> >that proposed that PSRs should be viewed as conditions on trees rather
> >than deriving them (was it Gazdar 77?).
> >
> >While we're at it does anyone know who first proposed that PSRs were
> >bottom to top projection rules rather than top to bottom replacement
> >rules?
> >
> >Arghghgh this is driving me crazy! I hate it when I can't remember simple
> >things like this.
> >
> >Best,
> >
> >A
> >
> >
> >------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> >	/ \			Andrew Carnie, Ph.D.
> >       /   \	  		Assoc. Professor of Linguistics
> >     	  / \    		Department of Linguistics
> >     	 /   \			Douglass 200E, University of Arizona
> >    	    / \			Tucson, AZ 85721
> >	   /   \
> >				Tel: (520) 621 2802  Cell: (520) 971 1166
> >				http://linguistics.arizona.edu/~carnie
> >
> >
>
>
>

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
	/ \			Andrew Carnie, Ph.D.
       /   \	  		Assoc. Professor of Linguistics
     	  / \    		Department of Linguistics
     	 /   \			Douglass 200E, University of Arizona
    	    / \			Tucson, AZ 85721
	   /   \
				Tel: (520) 621 2802  Cell: (520) 971 1166
				http://linguistics.arizona.edu/~carnie