Active & stative verbs in biclausal sentences.
R. Rankin
rankin at ku.edu
Sat Feb 14 15:39:47 UTC 2004
That's great, Rory -- thanks!
I was wondering if both verbs might use -(b)i if the subjects were the same but
only one might use -(b)i otherwise, but it's probably not that easy.
As for "deers don't get tired", I should have forseen that from my time in the
field and made the object of the first clause "his brother". My mistake.
Bob
----- Original Message -----
From: "Rory M Larson" <rlarson at unlnotes.unl.edu>
To: <siouan at lists.colorado.edu>
Sent: Friday, February 13, 2004 4:24 PM
Subject: Re: Active & stative verbs in biclausal sentences.
> Bob wrote:
> > So, in the language(s) YOU are studying, can
> > you have something like:
> >
> > 1. I ran fast and am very tired. (two conjugated verbs)
> >
> > And, then, in the sentence:
> >
> > 2. The boy chased the deer and (X) was very tired.
> >
> > Would the sentence, without any noun or pronoun mentioned for X, mean
> > "the boy chased the deer and he (the boy) was very tired" OR would it
> > mean "The boy chased the deer and he (the deer) was very tired."? Or
> > would it simply remain ambiguous? How do speakers treat this?
> I'm not sure this question can even be answered for OP. One of
> our long-standing frustrations in learning and teaching this
> language is that they just don't seem to have words that equate
> to our "and" and "or". Lakhota does, but OP doesn't. To put
> these sentences into modern Omaha, you'd probably just replace
> the "and" with a comma. At that point, of course, you just have
> two separate, short sentences.
>
> For what it's worth, I tried testing my Omaha translation of
> these two sentences with our speakers. Both were accepted.
>
> > 1. I ran fast and am very tired. (two conjugated verbs)
>
> AnoN'hegamaz^i, oNwoN'z^edha.
> I ran like mad; I'm tired.
>
> > 2. The boy chased the deer and (X) was very tired.
>
> Nu'z^iNga akha' ta'xti dhix^a', uz^e'dha.
> Boy the deer chased, he's tired.
>
> I asked who was tired in the second sentence, and it seemed
> obvious to the speakers that it was the boy. When I asked
> how to say "The boy chased the deer so the deer was tired",
> the arthritic elder speaker rejected the idea on grounds that
> "Deers don't get tired. They just go running and jumping all
> over the place."
>
> At this point, Mark drove them away. Maybe I can pick this
> up with them again later.
>
> Rory
>
>
More information about the Siouan
mailing list